* feat(sandbox): pluggable per-engine registry (postgres/redis/mongo) Replaces the hardcoded postgres+redis branches in the provisioner and the env emitter with a registry of SandboxEngine specs (image, run args, readiness probe, connection, ROBOCO_TEST_* env) in a pure low module (roboco/models/sandbox.py). VALID_SANDBOX_SERVICES is derived from the registry — single source of truth — and the provisioner + orchestrator iterate it, so adding an engine is one class + one registry line, not another branch. Adds a mongo:8-alpine engine (ROBOCO_TEST_MONGO_*) as the third service alongside postgres/redis. Also fixes the cold-pull loop that stranded v0.19.0 board agents with empty error strings: docker run pulled inline under a 20s deadline, so a NAS cold pull was killed, cancelled, and re-pulled from scratch forever. _ensure_image now inspects + pulls (300s) before run; provisioning errors log type+message so a bare TimeoutError no longer shows as "". Panel edit-project dialog: postgres/redis toggles -> a Set<string> multi-select driven by a SANDBOX_SERVICES catalog, so new engines appear in the UI by adding to the catalog. Tests: engine parity (allowlist==registry, unique slugs/images, no None leak in env, SandboxInfo aggregates every engine), mongo provision + env injection, plus the existing postgres/redis provision/env/spawn/janitor suite updated to the registry shape. 821 unit / 5 skip green; ruff + mypy (360 files) clean. * docs(sandbox): reflect pluggable engine registry + mongo across docs CHANGELOG (0.19.0): Added entry for the pluggable sandbox engine registry (postgres/redis/mongo) + Fixed entry for the cold-pull loop/empty-error strand that boarded v0.19.0 board agents. docs/map (9 files): sandbox subsystem blurbs, SandboxProvisioner rows, _maybe_provision_sandbox/_append_sandbox_env rows, feature-flag rows, the migration-057 row + v0.17.0 delta, and the models.md VALID_SANDBOX_SERVICES note — all retitled to DB/Redis/Mongo via the engine registry (roboco/models/sandbox.py), with the one-class-one-line extension story and the _ensure_image cold-pull fix. Production-network (roboco_data) lines left as postgres+redis — mongo is sandbox-only, not a prod service. docs/rag (3 files): sandbox-db.md rewritten around the registry (engine list, generic _provision_engine, image pre-pull, ROBOCO_TEST_DB_*/REDIS_*/MONGO_* incl. MONGO_AUTH_DB=admin, single emit_env); config-reference sandbox flag row + subsection retitled; db-network-isolation framing broadened to postgres/redis/mongo. preconditions-and-rejections left untouched (its hit was an unrelated gateway see-also link). * test(e2e): harden umbrella close terminal reads with bounded wait-for-state The MegaTask umbrella close test flaked once on CI (ceo-approve returned 200 but the re-fetch saw awaiting_pm_review) then passed on re-run. The production path is deterministic: complete -> main_pm_complete -> submit_pm_review -> escalate_to_ceo -> ceo_approve -> commit, all on one session, all awaited; the fire-and-forget completion hooks are isolated (own session, best-effort, never touch task.status or the request session). 20 local runs could not reproduce it. The one real surface is the read pattern: the e2e stack commits on the uvicorn thread's loop and reads via a separate loop (run_db -> asyncio.run with a fresh engine), so a terminal single point-read can race a still-draining completion hook on a contended runner. Replace the two terminal point-reads with a bounded wait_for_status poll. Strictly better than a one-shot read: absorbs the transient, and a genuine state bug still surfaces via the timeout branch asserting against the last-read state. --------- Co-authored-by: Renn F <rennf93@users.noreply.github.com>
47 KiB
Purpose
The AgentOrchestrator is the runtime brain of RoboCo: it owns the per-agent Docker container lifecycle, the per-tick dispatcher that matches tasks to agents, the stale-claim reaper, the provider rate-limit/overload park-and-probe recovery loop, and the default-off background engines (self-heal, CI-watch, dep-update, release-manager, strategy, external-PR poll, X-engine mentions poll, board roadmap engine, video render loop). It claims tasks on behalf of agents before spawning, injects briefings/manifests/git context at spawn time, provisions a per-spawn sandbox (postgres/redis/mongo via the engine registry) when opted in, captures per-session token usage, and persists durable runtime state (WaitingRecord, respawn_tracker) across restarts.
Files
| Path | Role | LOC |
|---|---|---|
| /Users/renzof/Documents/GitHub/ZZZ/roboco-master/roboco/roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py | Single 11485-line module: module helpers + the AgentOrchestrator class — container lifecycle, dispatchers, reaper, provider-parking, interactive intake/secretary spawns, background engine loops, token/cost capture, durable-state restore. | 11485 |
Key Symbols
| Name | Kind | File:Line | Responsibility |
|---|---|---|---|
| _system_api_headers | function | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:127 | System-identity headers (X-Agent-ID/Role/Token) for the orchestrator's internal self-API calls so silent recovery ops pass auth-required. |
| _is_coordination_task | function | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:395 | True for branchless tasks (product fan-out, ad-hoc cell map, MegaTask umbrella) via is_branchless_coordination; gates git-exemption sites. |
| _branch_is_expected | function | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:428 | True iff a code task should already have a branch_name (claimed/in_progress/verifying, non-coordination); gates the missing-branch readiness/stuck condition. |
| _agent_worktree_path | function | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:473 | Per-task worktree path under the clone root (F123) so parallel roots/tasks never clobber one shared checkout. |
| _agent_cwd_path | function | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:487 | ONE formula for the container cwd + Edit/Write allowlist scope (worktree when branch present, else clone root) so -w and the allowlist never drift. |
| _build_manifest_for_agent | function | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:560 | Write the per-role gateway SpawnManifest JSON to disk and return the host bind-mount path; None for non-gateway roles. |
| gateway_pre_spawn_check | function | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:687 | Consult trigger_filter spawn-cooldown + provider rate-limit tracker; returns spawn/queue/drop, degrades to spawn on any error. |
| AgentReadinessError | class | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:796 | Raised when spawn_agent refuses (task not ready / human role / worktree fatal); caller logs and moves on. |
| _SpawnAbortedDuringShutdown | class | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:804 | Signals a non-blocking intake/secretary spawn completed docker run after shutdown began; raiser already removed the container. |
| AgentOrchestrator.init | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:830 | Initialize instance/waiting/bg-task registries, locks (dispatch, supersede, intake/secretary spawn, respawn-persist), TTLs from settings, grok backoff state. |
| AgentOrchestrator.start | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:972 | Ensure agent image, restore WaitingRecord + respawn_tracker, reconcile orphan claims, readopt running containers, launch all background loops. |
| AgentOrchestrator.stop | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:1057 | Idempotent shutdown: cancel loops, stop agents (release_claim=True, skip provider-parked), drain bg writes, set _stopped. |
| AgentOrchestrator._drain_bg_tasks | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:1031 | Bounded wait for fire-and-forget bg writes to commit before exit; cancels past _SHUTDOWN_DRAIN_TIMEOUT_SECONDS. |
| AgentOrchestrator._ensure_agent_image | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:1110 | Build/pull base + role-specialized agent Docker images; idempotent; registry-mode pulls pre-built images. |
| AgentOrchestrator._get_role_permissions | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:1313 | Build the Edit/Write/Read allowlist scoped to the agent's cwd (worktree or clone root) and cell workspace for documenters. |
| AgentOrchestrator._fable_hook_groups | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:1414 | Default-off (fable_mode_enabled) Claude-path hook groups for 5 vendored fable-mode scripts (stop-gate/bash-discipline/honesty-nudge/prompt-nudge/precompact); appended AFTER RoboCo's own per-event hooks inside _generate_agent_settings. |
| AgentOrchestrator._task_git_context | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:1685 | Build SpawnGitContext from a task payload; sets task_short_id (first 8 chars) only when a branch exists. |
| AgentOrchestrator._safe_spawn | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:1816 | Build SpawnInputs and delegate to the resolved AgentProvider (grok) or built-in _spawn_container path. |
| AgentOrchestrator._prepare_agent_spawn | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:1930 | Resolve project/team/cwd, ensure worktree, generate settings/permissions, write briefing + MCP config, compose prompt, ensure image, register STARTING instance. |
| AgentOrchestrator._ensure_worktree_before_spawn | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:2001 | Idempotently re-attach a pruned task worktree before -w lands on it; fatal WorkspaceError releases claim + aborts, transient aborts without release. |
| AgentOrchestrator.spawn_agent | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:2141 | Chokepoint spawn entry: validate path-segment, refuse human-only roles, readiness gate, resolve git context, provider-park pre-check, TOCTOU re-check, prepare + launch. |
| AgentOrchestrator._resolve_host_paths | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:2297 | Compute host bind-mount paths for containerized vs host runtime (docs/workspaces/claude/mcp/grok-usage/prompt/settings/briefing). |
| AgentOrchestrator._spawn_container | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:2664 | Run the Claude Code SDK container via docker with all mounts/env/manifest/cwd args; returns container id. |
| AgentOrchestrator._generate_mcp_config | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:2779 | Write the per-agent MCP servers config (flow/do/git-readonly/optimal/docs) to disk and return the path. |
| AgentOrchestrator._generate_composed_prompt | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:2946 | Compose the spawn prompt (identity + task briefing + ambient conventions block + tool-load block) via compose_prompt. |
| AgentOrchestrator._resolve_conventions_ambient | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:2998 | Resolve the in-scope projects for the ambient architectural-conventions block (single repo / product / ad-hoc cell map). |
| AgentOrchestrator._readiness_gate | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:3104 | Pre-flight refusal: missing project/cell-map, missing AC, role/status mismatch, missing git token, bad task shape, unmet dependencies. |
| AgentOrchestrator._write_agent_briefing | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:3431 | Fetch task + institutional memory + workflow state and render the per-agent briefing markdown at the cwd path. |
| AgentOrchestrator.start_intake_session | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:3612 | Open the intake relay + schedule the guarded spawn of the single persistent intake container. |
| AgentOrchestrator._spawn_intake_container | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:3715 | Spawn the intake container under _intake_spawn_lock: clone intake scope, build cmd, run, abort-if-shutdown, register instance, record usage session. |
| AgentOrchestrator._spawn_secretary_container | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:3918 | Spawn the secretary container under _secretary_spawn_lock with authenticated identity env; same abort-if-shutdown shape as intake. |
| AgentOrchestrator._reap_idle_interactive_sessions | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:4038 | Reap idle intake/secretary containers past interactive_idle_reap_seconds. |
| AgentOrchestrator._clone_intake_scope | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:4137 | Clone the intake chat's project/product/multi-project scope into the intake workspace; returns cwd + cloned slug list. |
| AgentOrchestrator.stop_agent | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:4412 | Stop a container; release_claim=True hands the claimed task back to the pool now (skips provider-parked); finalizes usage session. |
| AgentOrchestrator._release_stopped_agent_claim | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:4517 | Idempotent unclaim_for_reaper on a stopped agent's task; best-effort, reaper backstops. |
| AgentOrchestrator._persist_respawn_record | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:4658 | Atomic ON CONFLICT DO UPDATE upsert of one respawn_tracker row under _respawn_persist_lock so commits land in logical schedule order. |
| AgentOrchestrator._record_spawn_session | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:4804 | Insert an agent_spawn_sessions row + pin its id on the instance for usage attribution. |
| AgentOrchestrator._finalize_spawn_session | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:5059 | Resolve final token usage (Claude transcript or grok usage.json), update the spawn session row, publish USAGE_SNAPSHOT, evict instance. |
| AgentOrchestrator._sweep_token_snapshots | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:5262 | Periodic live-usage snapshot sweep across active agents; finalizes stopped ones; budget-exceeded termination. |
| AgentOrchestrator._enforce_grok_cost_budget | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:4952 | Kill live grok containers whose captured cost exceeds grok_max_cost_usd; release_claim=True. |
| AgentOrchestrator.restore_waiting_records | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:5479 | Repopulate _waiting_records from the WaitingRecordTable at startup. |
| AgentOrchestrator.restore_respawn_tracker | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:5561 | Repopulate _pm_respawn_tracker from respawn_tracker rows, re-stamping last_check/last_status to live values, evicting terminal/missing rows. |
| AgentOrchestrator._partition_respawn_rows | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:5515 | Split restored respawn rows into restorable vs evict (terminal/missing task). |
| AgentOrchestrator.resolve_wait | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:5606 | Resume a waiting agent: respawn FIRST then tear down the record only once a container launched (keeps record through a provider re-park bail). |
| AgentOrchestrator._health_loop | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:5728 | Periodic _check_health pass over all instances. |
| AgentOrchestrator._sweeper_loop | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:5739 | Periodic _run_sweep: superseded PRs, dangling images, transcript retention, budget exceeded. |
| AgentOrchestrator._check_health | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:6256 | Per-agent docker inspect; on exit, route through _maybe_park_for_exit_error / _crash_retry_or_escalate / _handle_stopped_container. |
| AgentOrchestrator._inspect_container_state | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:6014 | docker inspect with _DOCKER_INSPECT_TIMEOUT_SECONDS; returns (is_running, exit_code); per-agent failure skips that agent. |
| AgentOrchestrator._resolve_container_id | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:6047 | Resolve a container id by name for re-adoption so _check_health sees the real id. |
| AgentOrchestrator._probe_gateway_health | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:6077 | Out-of-band docker exec gateway-venv import probe for broken-but-alive agents; timed via _DOCKER_EXEC_TIMEOUT_SECONDS. |
| AgentOrchestrator._maybe_park_for_exit_error | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:6115 | Detect session-limit/overload markers in dead container output + transcript tail; park provider instead of crash-retrying. |
| AgentOrchestrator._maybe_recover_broken_gateway | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:8689 | Kill + evict a broken-but-alive agent past gateway_health_grace_seconds so it falls through to release + respawn. |
| AgentOrchestrator._strategy_engine_loop | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:6360 | Default-off strategy engine tick loop (gated by strategy_engine_enabled). |
| AgentOrchestrator._external_pr_poll_loop | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:6383 | Poll inbound external PRs for review (external_pr_enabled / internal_pr_enabled). |
| AgentOrchestrator._self_heal_loop | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:6411 | Single-repo self-heal CI-watch tick loop (self_heal_enabled). |
| AgentOrchestrator._ci_watch_loop | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:6446 | Multi-repo CI-watch tick loop (ci_watch_enabled); _load_ci_watch_set one per (repo, workflow). |
| AgentOrchestrator._dep_update_loop | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:6534 | Dependency-update bot tick loop (dep_update_enabled); _load_dep_update_set one per (repo, command). |
| AgentOrchestrator._release_manager_loop | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:6576 | Gated release-manager readiness sweep tick loop (release_manager_enabled). |
| AgentOrchestrator._projects_one_per_key | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:6665 | Collapse projects to one canonical (by slug) per distinct key (repo / (repo,workflow) / (repo,command)). |
| AgentOrchestrator._rate_limit_probe_loop | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:6926 | Probe parked providers every 30s; resume waiting agents on success; orphan-provider fallback for untracker-listed parks. |
| AgentOrchestrator._provider_spawn_parked | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:7016 | True when the provider is currently rate-limited/overloaded parked (spawn short-circuit). |
| AgentOrchestrator._park_provider_unavailable | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:7172 | Park an agent + provider: stop container, register rate_limit_lifted WaitingRecord, persist it, activate tracker. |
| AgentOrchestrator._park_grok_rate_limited | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:7233 | Park a grok agent on xAI 429 (exit 75) with exponential re-park backoff within one episode. |
| AgentOrchestrator._park_grok_auth_unavailable | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:7268 | Park a grok agent on missing/expired auth token (exit 78). |
| AgentOrchestrator._on_probe_failure | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:7350 | Count failed probes; CEO-notify once at threshold; past _PROBE_GIVE_UP_THRESHOLD fall back to time-expiry optimism (clear park + resume). |
| AgentOrchestrator._readopt_running_agents | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:8547 | At startup, re-adopt surviving containers into _instances as ACTIVE with real container ids; inert when nothing runs. |
| AgentOrchestrator._should_skip_live_reap | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:8750 | Spare a live container from reaping UNLESS wedged (grok) or gateway-broken past grace (those kill+evict). |
| AgentOrchestrator._assignee_is_provider_parked | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:8527 | True if a task's assignee is provider-parked; reaper skips it so the claim survives for probe-resume. |
| AgentOrchestrator._reap_with_service | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:8770 | Inner stale-claim reaper: skip live (unless wedged/broken), skip provider-parked, unclaim_for_reaper the rest. |
| AgentOrchestrator._maybe_provision_sandbox | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:2029 | Provision this spawn's sandbox engines (postgres/redis/mongo via SandboxProvisioner + the SANDBOX_ENGINES registry) when sandbox_db_enabled + the project's sandbox_services are set; None (byte-for-byte legacy path) otherwise. Fail-loud once opted in — a provisioning failure refuses the spawn. |
| AgentOrchestrator._append_sandbox_env | staticmethod | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:2639 | Inject the sandbox's ROBOCO_TEST_* env (postgres ROBOCO_TEST_DB_* / redis ROBOCO_TEST_REDIS_* / mongo ROBOCO_TEST_MONGO_*) via SandboxInfo.emit_env over the engine registry, called INSTEAD OF _append_gate_env whenever a sandbox was provisioned for this spawn. Emission is registry-driven, so a new engine's env vars land here with no orchestrator change. |
| AgentOrchestrator._sandbox_janitor_sweep | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:9426 | Best-effort: remove sandbox containers whose owner agent is gone; rides the reaper tick, error-isolated. |
| AgentOrchestrator._x_mentions_poll_loop | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:7431 | Default-off X-engine mentions-poll tick loop (x_engine_enabled); release-post drafts are event-driven, not from this loop. |
| AgentOrchestrator._run_x_mentions_cycle | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:7453 | One mentions-poll pass: get_x_engine(db).run_cycle() + commit; testable without the sleep. |
| AgentOrchestrator._x_feature_spotlight_loop | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:7571 | Default-off X-engine feature-spotlight tick loop (x_engine_enabled AND x_feature_spotlight_enabled); opens one held Head-of-Marketing exploration task per x_feature_spotlight_interval_seconds (default 3d). |
| AgentOrchestrator._run_x_feature_spotlight_cycle | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:7591 | One feature-spotlight pass: get_x_engine(db).open_feature_spotlight_exploration() + commit; testable without the sleep. |
| AgentOrchestrator._roadmap_engine_loop | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:7462 | Default-off board roadmap-engine tick loop (roadmap_engine_enabled); opens one held exploration cycle per interval. |
| AgentOrchestrator._run_roadmap_engine_cycle | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:7484 | One roadmap-engine pass: get_roadmap_engine(db).run_cycle() + commit; testable without the sleep. |
| AgentOrchestrator._dispatch_roadmap_exploration | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:10284 | One-shot Product-Owner spawn to author a themed roadmap cycle; bypasses the two-reviewer board-review-pair machinery (PO-solo in v1). |
| AgentOrchestrator._dispatch_feature_spotlight_exploration | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:10424 | One-shot Head-of-Marketing spawn to investigate + call propose_feature_spotlight once; _dispatch_pm_work routes source=x_feature_exploration to it before the generic board-review check, mirroring the roadmap source's own early branch. |
| AgentOrchestrator._build_feature_spotlight_prompt | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:12827 | Render the one-shot feature-spotlight exploration prompt (investigate CHANGELOG/flags/docs/charter/KB, call propose_feature_spotlight once, then i_am_idle). |
| AgentOrchestrator._dispatch_all_work | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:8814 | Reset tick-handled set, reap stale claims, enforce grok budget, run all 17 dispatchers under one httpx client with per-dispatcher isolation. |
| AgentOrchestrator._pm_respawn_should_gate | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:8915 | Per-(slug,task) respawn circuit breaker; tracing_gap rule-following resets (bounded) + durable persist; CEO notify once when tripped. |
| AgentOrchestrator._handle_pm_assigned_task | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:9084 | Spawn/respawn the PM for an assigned coordination root subject to the respawn gate. |
| AgentOrchestrator._AUTO_SUBMIT_VERB_BY_ROLE | ClassVar[dict] | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:10650 | Wave-1 PR-gate turn cut: maps cell_pm -> (cell_pm, submit_up) and main_pm -> (main_pm, submit_root), the flow route+verb that assembles the parent's PR for each coordinator role. |
| AgentOrchestrator._auto_submit_target | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:10655 | Resolve (role, route, verb, pm_uuid) for an auto-submittable parent; None when pr_gate_auto_submit_enabled is off, the parent is branchless coordination (no PR to assemble), the role has no submit verb, or no PM identity resolves. |
| AgentOrchestrator._try_auto_submit | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:10677 | Wave-1 PR-gate turn cut: run the owning PM's submit_up/submit_root verb system-side via the internal flow API (no PM spawn) when every child of an assembled parent is terminal; True on gate acceptance (fires task.auto_submitted audit + _mark_task_handled), False on ANY refusal (flag off, branchless parent, unmapped role, gate rejection, or transport error) so the caller falls back to the classic PM closure spawn. |
| AgentOrchestrator._closure_handled_without_pm | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:10740 | Recover an auto-paused/blocked parent's status first (so the next actor lands on an actionable in_progress parent), then try _try_auto_submit; True skips the PM closure spawn entirely. |
| AgentOrchestrator._maybe_spawn_pm_closure | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:10768 | If this parent task is ready for closure, try the system-side submit turn cut first (_closure_handled_without_pm); only spawn its PM when that declines (debounced via _is_recently_paused). |
| AgentOrchestrator._dispatch_dev_work | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:9733 | Fetch pending/needs_revision/in_progress/claimed code tasks and route each through _dev_dispatch_one. |
| AgentOrchestrator._dev_dispatch_one | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:9861 | Per-task dev dispatch: HITL skip, role/type mismatch guard, existing-owner respawn or pending spawn. |
| AgentOrchestrator._spawn_pending_dev | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:9800 | Validate + spawn a dev for a pre-assigned pending task; applies the per-dev lane barrier _blocked_by_earlier_lane_sibling. |
| AgentOrchestrator._blocked_by_earlier_sibling | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:10183 | MERGE barrier: hold a higher-sequence same-team sibling's review/merge until earlier siblings land (shared cell branch ordering). |
| AgentOrchestrator._blocked_by_earlier_lane_sibling | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:10234 | Per-dev LANE barrier: hold a dev's higher-sequence code leaf until its own lower-sequence code siblings under the same parent are terminal. |
| AgentOrchestrator._dispatch_pm_review_work | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:10299 | Dispatch awaiting_pm_review to cell/main PM; applies _blocked_by_earlier_sibling; human-role skip + respawn gate. |
| AgentOrchestrator._dispatch_a2a_work | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:10904 | Spawn targets of unacknowledged a2a_request notifications; skips human-only roles (CEO/prompter/secretary). |
| AgentOrchestrator._build_dev_prompt | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:11053 | Render the dev spawn prompt with workflow state + instructions. |
| is_unattributed_delivery_spawn | function | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:415 | True when a delivery-role (developer/qa/documenter) spawn carries no task_id; warns on unattributed usage without noise from intentionally taskless roles. |
| AgentOrchestrator._flush_respawn_tracker | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:1105 | Unbounded flush of the full in-memory PM-respawn snapshot called after _drain_bg_tasks in stop() so a deadline-cancelled fire-and-forget persist can't leave the durable count lagging. |
| AgentOrchestrator._confirm_resume_liveness | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:5798 | Tears down a resumed agent's WaitingRecord only after confirming the container is still alive past _resume_confirm_delay (30s); a container that dies immediately keeps its record for the probe-resume orphan fallback. |
| AgentOrchestrator._new_strategy_loop_state | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:6538 | Factory for _StrategyLoopState (consecutive-failure tracking for _strategy_engine_loop). |
| AgentOrchestrator._strategy_engine_cycle | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:6541 | One strategy-engine pass; resets the failure counter on success and CEO-notifies once per failure episode past _STRATEGY_FAIL_CEO_NOTIFY_THRESHOLD. |
| AgentOrchestrator._notify_strategy_engine_failure | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:6568 | Send one CEO alert that the strategy engine is persistently failing. |
| AgentOrchestrator._repo_key | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:6839 | Normalized repo identity (delegates to converters.repo_key): strips .git, trailing slash, lowercases — shared by the poll-set collapse and the DB dedupe queries so ci-watch/dep-update use one normalization. |
| AgentOrchestrator._agent_holds_live_claim | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:8755 | True when a slug owns a non-terminal task; used by _readopt_running_agents to skip zombie containers whose claim was already released. |
| AgentOrchestrator._stuck_claude_slug | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:8953 | Slug of an ACTIVE non-GROK container holding a task with heartbeat stale past claude_stuck_kill_seconds; None when not eligible. |
| AgentOrchestrator._maybe_kill_stuck_claude | method | roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py:8988 | Kill + evict a stuck non-GROK container past claude_stuck_kill_seconds so the reaper can release its task; called from _should_skip_live_reap. |
Data Flow
Inputs: the dispatcher loop polls the orchestrator's own HTTP API (httpx AsyncClient with _system_api_headers) for tasks by status (pending/awaiting_qa/blocked/awaiting_pm_review/...) and for notifications (a2a_request/escalation/approval/audit); it also reads Docker state (docker inspect/exec/run) and Redis (RateLimitStateTracker) and the DB (TaskTable, WaitingRecordTable, RespawnTrackerTable, GatewayTriggerTable, agent_spawn_sessions, daily_usage_rollups) via get_session_factory / get_db_context. Control: _dispatcher_loop ticks every dispatcher_interval (30s) or on _dispatch_wake.set() from API routes (trigger_dispatch). Each tick: _reap_stale_claims -> _enforce_grok_cost_budget -> 17 dispatchers in order, each fetching tasks and calling spawn_agent (or _spawn_assigned_qa / _spawn_pending_dev / etc.). spawn_agent: readiness gate -> resolve git context -> provider-park pre-check (cheap, via _resolve_agent_route + _provider_spawn_parked) -> self._lock TOCTOU re-check -> _prepare_agent_spawn (writes settings/permissions/briefing/MCP config/manifest, ensures worktree via WorkspaceService.ensure_worktree_for_resume, ensures image) -> _launch_spawn -> _safe_spawn -> _spawn_container (docker run) or provider (grok). Outputs: registered AgentInstance in _instances, agent_spawn_sessions row pinned for usage, audit_log agent.spawned event, container running with mounted manifest + briefing + cwd at the worktree. On container exit: _check_health reads docker inspect, _maybe_park_for_exit_error parks the provider on session-limit/overload markers (registering a rate_limit_lifted WaitingRecord + persisting it + activating the tracker), else _crash_retry_or_escalate / _handle_stopped_container; _finalize_spawn_session resolves tokens from the Claude transcript (/usage/sync) or grok usage.json, updates daily_usage_rollups, publishes USAGE_SNAPSHOT to /ws/system. Recovery: _rate_limit_probe_loop probes parked providers every 30s, on success _on_probe_success clears the tracker + resume waiting agents via resolve_wait (respawn FIRST, delete record only after a real launch). Durable state: _persist_respawn_record / _persist_waiting_record write through to DB under respawn_persist_lock; restore*_at startup repopulates the in-memory registries. Callers: the FastAPI lifespan (roboco/api/bootstrap) constructs and starts/stops the singleton; API routes call trigger_dispatch, spawn_agent, stop_agent, start_intake_session, spawn_secretary_session, supersede_external_pr, get_status_summary.
Mermaid
stateDiagram-v2
direction TB
[*] --> start: lifespan
start --> Running: restore_waiting_records + restore_respawn_tracker + reconcile_orphans + readopt_running_agents + launch loops
Running --> Stopping: stop()
Stopping --> [*]: cancel loops + stop agents (release_claim) + drain_bg_tasks + _stopped
state Running {
[*] --> dispatcher_wait
dispatcher_wait --> tick: wake | 30s
tick --> reap: _reap_stale_claims
reap --> spawn_pass: _dispatch_all_work (17 dispatchers)
spawn_pass --> dispatcher_wait
}
state spawn_pass {
[*] --> spawn_agent
spawn_agent --> readiness: _readiness_gate
readiness --> refuse: not ready (auto-block)
readiness --> park_check: ready
park_check --> offline: provider parked
park_check --> prepare: clear
prepare --> ensure_worktree
ensure_worktree --> abort_fatal: WorkspaceError (release claim)
ensure_worktree --> launch: ok
launch --> registered: docker run + record session
}
state reap {
[*] --> stale_check
stale_check --> skip_live: live & not wedged
stale_check --> skip_parked: provider-parked
stale_check --> unclaim: stale
}
Logical Tree
- AgentOrchestrator
- Startup (
start): restore WaitingRecord + respawn_tracker → reconcile orphan claims →_readopt_running_agents→ launch background loops - Dispatch:
_dispatch_all_work(reap → grok budget → 17 dispatchers under one httpx client) ticked by_dispatcher_loop(30s or_dispatch_wake.set()) - Spawn:
spawn_agentchokepoint →_readiness_gate→ provider-park pre-check →_prepare_agent_spawn(worktree/permissions/briefing/MCP/manifest) →_safe_spawn→_spawn_containeror GrokCliProvider - Health/reaper:
_check_health(docker inspect) →_maybe_park_for_exit_error|_crash_retry_or_escalate|_handle_stopped_container;_reap_stale_claimsvia_should_skip_live_reap+_maybe_recover_broken_gateway - Rate-limit/overload park-and-probe:
_park_provider_unavailable(+ grok 75/78 variants) →_rate_limit_probe_loop(30s) →_on_probe_success/_on_probe_failure→resolve_wait - Gateway-health:
_probe_gateway_health→_gateway_broken_past_grace→_maybe_recover_broken_gateway(kill+evict) - Respawn tracker:
_pm_respawn_should_gate→_persist_respawn_record(durable upsert) +restore_respawn_trackerat startup - PM closure / PR-gate turn cut (wave 1):
_maybe_spawn_pm_closure→_closure_handled_without_pm(recover paused/blocked status) →_try_auto_submit(system-side submit_up/submit_root via_AUTO_SUBMIT_VERB_BY_ROLE, gated bypr_gate_auto_submit_enabled); only a gate refusal falls through to an actual PM spawn - Default-off loops:
_self_heal_loop,_ci_watch_loop,_dep_update_loop,_release_manager_loop,_strategy_engine_loop,_external_pr_poll_loop,_x_mentions_poll_loop,_roadmap_engine_loop - Interactive:
start_intake_session/_spawn_intake_container/_spawn_secretary_container/_reap_idle_interactive_sessions - Shutdown (
stop): cancel loops →stop_agent(release_claim=True)(skip provider-parked) →_drain_bg_tasks→_stopped
- Startup (
Dependencies
- Internal:
roboco.config.settings;roboco.db.base.get_session_factory; tablesRespawnTrackerTable,WaitingRecordTable,TaskTable,GatewayTriggerTable,agent_spawn_sessions,daily_usage_rollups;roboco.events.get_event_bus;roboco.llm.providers(ClaudeCodeProvider,GrokCliProvider,grok_auth);roboco.services.gateway(RateLimitStateTracker,role_config,claim_guards);WorkspaceService,TaskService,GitService,ConventionsService,SequencingService,CiWatchEngine,DepUpdateEngine,ReleaseManagerEngine,ReleaseReadinessService,MemoryDistiller;roboco.runtime.sandbox.SandboxProvisioner;roboco.services.x_engine.get_x_engine;roboco.services.roadmap_engine.get_roadmap_engine;roboco.runtime.compose_prompt;AGENT_IMAGES. - External: Docker daemon (inspect/exec/run/rm); Redis; PostgreSQL+pgvector; Ollama; Claude Code SDK container image; grok CLI +
~/.grok/auth.json; the orchestrator's own HTTP API (/tasks,/notifications,/audit) via httpx with_system_api_headers.
Entry Points
- FastAPI lifespan start →
AgentOrchestrator.start()(bootstrap constructs singleton). - FastAPI lifespan shutdown →
stop()(idempotent; bootstrapfinallyre-calls as safety net). _dispatcher_looptick (30s or_dispatch_wake.set()from APItrigger_dispatch)._health_loop(per-instance inspect),_sweeper_loop(superseded PRs, dangling images, transcript retention, grok budget),_rate_limit_probe_loop(30s).- Default-off loop ticks: self-heal / ci-watch / dep-update / release-manager / strategy / external-PR poll.
- API routes:
spawn_agent,stop_agent,start_intake_session,spawn_secretary_session,supersede_external_pr,get_status_summary.
Config Flags
ROBOCO_OVERLOAD_BREAK_ENABLED(default-on) — park on 529/500/503 + Claude session-limit 429.ROBOCO_GATEWAY_HEALTH_ENABLED(default-on) — broken-gateway probe + kill past grace.ROBOCO_SELF_HEAL_ENABLED+ROBOCO_SELF_HEAL_ORIGINATE_ENABLED— single-repo CI-watch loop.ROBOCO_CI_WATCH_ENABLED(+_INTERVAL_SECONDS/_MAX_OPEN_TASKS/_MAX_PER_CYCLE/_DEFAULT_WORKFLOW) — multi-repo CI-watch.ROBOCO_DEP_UPDATE_ENABLED(+_INTERVAL_SECONDSdefault 604800) — dependency-update bot.ROBOCO_RELEASE_MANAGER_ENABLED(+_MIN_COMMITS/_INTERVAL_SECONDS) — gated release manager.ROBOCO_STRATEGY_ENGINE_ENABLED,ROBOCO_RESEARCH_ENABLED,ROBOCO_EXTERNAL_PR_REVIEW_ENABLED/ROBOCO_INTERNAL_PR_REVIEW_ENABLED— strategy / research / external-PR poll.ROBOCO_GROK_MAX_COST_USD— grok budget kill-switch;_GROK_RATE_LIMIT_EXIT_CODE=75,_GROK_AUTH_EXIT_CODE=78,_PROBE_GIVE_UP_THRESHOLD=30.ROBOCO_CLAUDE_STUCK_KILL_SECONDS(default 3600, min 600) — heartbeat-stale kill threshold for non-GROK agents; controls_maybe_kill_stuck_claude.ROBOCO_DISPATCHER_INTERVAL_SECONDS(30),ROBOCO_INTERACTIVE_IDLE_REAP_SECONDS,ROBOCO_GROK_*backoff constants.ROBOCO_SANDBOX_DB_ENABLED(default off) — master switch for the sandboxed per-agent-spawn engine provisioner (_maybe_provision_sandbox/_append_sandbox_env/_sandbox_janitor_sweep); a project participates only when itssandbox_servicescolumn is also set. The service set is theSANDBOX_ENGINESregistry (postgres / redis / mongo); adding an engine needs no orchestrator or env-emitter change.ROBOCO_DB_NETWORK_ISOLATED(default off; set by the compose topology that carries theroboco_datanetwork) — suppresses the legacy_append_gate_envprod-creds injection when postgres/redis are unreachable from the agent mesh.ROBOCO_CLOUD_AUTH_ENABLED(+_EMAIL/_PASSWORD/_SECRET/_COOKIE_MAX_AGE, default off) — cloud auth master switch; read byroboco.api.deps.get_agent_context/roboco.api.auth.*, not the orchestrator itself, but gates whether a spawned agent's own HMAC-token identity path is the sole non-CEO auth route.ROBOCO_X_ENGINE_ENABLED(+_mentions_interval_seconds/_mentions_max_per_cycle/_mentions_min_engagement/_max_open_posts/_account_user_id/_request_timeout_seconds, default off) — gates_x_mentions_poll_loop.ROBOCO_ROADMAP_ENGINE_ENABLED(+_interval_secondsdefault 604800 /_min_items_per_cycle/_max_items_per_cycle, default off) — gates_roadmap_engine_loop.ROBOCO_X_FEATURE_SPOTLIGHT_ENABLED(+_interval_secondsdefault 259200/3d, default off, sub-switch ofx_engine_enabled) — gates_x_feature_spotlight_loop.ROBOCO_FABLE_MODE_ENABLED(default off) — gates_fable_hook_groups(Claude-path hook install) and, viaroboco/agents/factories/_base.py, thefable_doctrine_layerprompt layer; off = byte-for-byte unchanged spawn path.ROBOCO_PR_GATE_AUTO_SUBMIT_ENABLED(pr_gate_auto_submit_enabled, default True) — wave-1 PR-gate turn cut: when every child of an assembled parent is terminal,_try_auto_submitruns the owning PM's submit_up/submit_root gate system-side instead of spawning the PM for that turn; a gate rejection (freshness/integrity) falls back to the classic PM closure spawn.
Gotchas
- Respawn-tracker rows are restored at startup and re-stamped to live values; terminal/missing-task rows are evicted, so a stale row can't gate a fresh task. The upsert is race-free but fire-and-forget persists are ordered by
_respawn_persist_lockacquisition (= schedule order); a stale persist resolving after a fresh one would otherwise re-burn the strike threshold on restart. _instancesis reconciled-from-Docker at startup (_readopt_running_agents), NOT persisted — a surviving container is re-adopted as ACTIVE with its real container id so_check_health(which skipscontainer_id is None) sees it.- Session-limit 429 parking reads the Claude Code SDK transcript tail, not docker logs —
_maybe_park_for_exit_errordetects the marker in the dead container output + transcript; docker logs alone miss it. - Grok exit 78 (auth missing/expired) parks with
kind="auth_missing";grok_auth.refresh_if_stalemints a fresh token per dispatch tick, and the entrypoint backstop refuses start instead of hanging at an interactive login prompt. - Human-only roles (CEO/prompter/secretary) are never spawned:
spawn_agentrefuses and_dispatch_a2a_workskips notification targets that are human roles — a2a requests to them are silently dropped (no delivery lifecycle). - Fire-and-forget
_bg_tasks(respawn_tracker upserts, audit rows) are drained at shutdown under_SHUTDOWN_DRAIN_TIMEOUT_SECONDS; past the deadline they're cancelled, so a cancelled persist degrades to in-memory-only (can only suppress a spawn, never manufacture one). - Budget-kill (
_enforce_grok_cost_budget) finalizes the spawn session BEFORE popping the instance so captured usage/cost isn't lost; the reaper then releases the freed claim. _should_skip_live_reapshort-circuits like the originaland: when not live, none of the three kill checks is awaited. The three kill paths are:_maybe_kill_wedged_grok(grok idle TTL),_maybe_kill_stuck_claude(non-GROK agent stuck pastclaude_stuck_kill_seconds, default 3600s), and_maybe_recover_broken_gateway. A Claude agent stuck in a genuine verb loop (still firing gateway verbs, so heartbeat advances) remains spared — the stuck-claude TTL only catches heartbeat-stale containers._try_auto_submitposts to the internal flow API AS the owning PM (X-Agent-ID/X-Agent-Roleheaders set to the PM's own identity) — it is not a privilege escalation since the PM already owns that verb, but it means anauto_submittedgate action is indistinguishable in the PM's own audit trail from one it issued itself; thetask.auto_submittedaudit event (fired only from_try_auto_submit) is the sole marker that the PM turn was skipped._auto_submit_targetrequires BOTHbranch_nameandproject_idon the parent — a MegaTask umbrella (branchless coordination) always fails this check and falls through to the classic PM closure spawn, which is correct (an umbrella assembles no PR) but means the turn cut never applies to the top of a MegaTask tree, only its root-subtasks.
Drift from CLAUDE.md
- None material. The orchestrator runs the six default-off loops CLAUDE.md lists (self-heal, CI-watch, dep-update, release-manager, strategy, external-PR poll);
ROBOCO_ORG_MEMORY_ENABLEDhas no orchestrator loop (capture/retrieval live inTaskService/EvidenceRepo, by design). Respawn-tracker durability (migration 051),_instancesreconciled-from-Docker, and the park-and-probe shape all match the prose.
Changes Since Baseline
git log fd10cc862c..HEAD -- roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py (+1370/-361):
15effce0Chore: 141 Gaps fill-in (#283) — bulk gap closure; orchestrator touchups across spawn/readiness/dispatch paths.3aff6e04Chore: Close gaps (#285) — MegaTask per-cell project map:_ambient_projects_for_task+_resolve_subtask_projectfan-out generalized to first-distinct-project-of-map-or-product; multi-cell root-subtask intake/cloning wired.
Post-snapshot updates (since 2026-06-29):
536bbb64Chore/all/logical gaps sweep (#286) — Cluster O hardening:_confirm_resume_livenessfixes the park/probe revival race (#71);_flush_respawn_trackercalled unbounded after_drain_bg_tasksinstop()to fix re-burn on restart (#74);_maybe_kill_stuck_claude+_stuck_claude_slug+_agent_holds_live_claimadded to kill non-GROK agents stuck pastclaude_stuck_kill_seconds(#73);_should_skip_live_reapnow chains three kill checks (grok-wedged, stuck-claude, gateway-broken);_strategy_engine_looprefactored into_strategy_engine_cycle+_notify_strategy_engine_failurewith consecutive-failure CEO alert (#193);is_unattributed_delivery_spawn+_TASKLESS_SPAWN_SUSPECT_ROLESwarn on delivery-role spawns with no task_id (#11);_repo_keydelegates toconverters.repo_keyfor git_url normalization;spawn_agenthuman-role guard usesis_human_only_role()from foundation.identity;_ensure_worktree_before_spawnnow heals a vanished clone root viaWorkspaceService._is_workspace_healthy+ensure_workspacebeforeensure_worktree_self_heal.d34bc1a7ci-watch/dep-update dedupe:_repo_keynormalizes git_url (strip.git, trailing slash, lowercase) and empty-string workflow treated as default so the DB dedupe and the orchestrator poll-set collapse agree.7be10057Agent image: stop bakingVIRTUAL_ENV=/app/.venv— comment in_generate_mcp_configupdated to drop the stale VIRTUAL_ENV reference.6b441e42Converters:InvalidIdentifierErrornow caught explicitly in_release_stopped_agent_claimwith a structured warning log instead of a silent broad-except return.d1cf6ecbWave 1: PR-gate turn cut, task search, trace timestamps, Secretary edits + e2e scenarios 2–3 (#295) — addsconfig.pr_gate_auto_submit_enabled(default True) +_AUTO_SUBMIT_VERB_BY_ROLE/_auto_submit_target/_try_auto_submit/_closure_handled_without_pm, wired into_maybe_spawn_pm_closureso an assembled, all-children-terminal parent is submitted to the PR gate system-side instead of always spawning the PM for that turn; fires a newtask.auto_submittedaudit event.- v0.18.0 (2026-07-04): Fable mode —
_fable_hook_groups(orchestrator.py:1414) appends 5 vendored hook scripts after RoboCo's own inside_generate_agent_settings, gated byfable_mode_enabled(default off). X feature-spotlight —_x_feature_spotlight_loop/_run_x_feature_spotlight_cycle(mirrors_x_mentions_poll_loop's shape) +_dispatch_feature_spotlight_exploration/_build_feature_spotlight_prompt(mirrors the roadmap engine's one-shot board-solo dispatch) open a held Head-of-Marketing exploration task everyx_feature_spotlight_interval_seconds, gated byx_feature_spotlight_enabled(sub-switch ofx_engine_enabled, both default off).
Regression Risks
| Title | File:Line | Claim | Severity |
|---|---|---|---|
| orchestrator.py:5798 | resolve_wait respawns FIRST and deletes the WaitingRecord only after a real launch; if the respawn succeeds but the container dies immediately the record is gone and the task strands until the reaper's TTL.536bbb64): _confirm_resume_liveness keeps the record past the launch and tears it down only once the agent is confirmed alive past 30s; a dead container keeps its record for the probe-resume orphan fallback. |
||
| Gateway-health over-reap of live containers | orchestrator.py:8689 | _maybe_recover_broken_gateway kills a live container past gateway_health_grace_seconds; a transient-but-recurring probe miss (None clears the mark, but a flaky false-broken streak) could kill a healthy agent mid-long-edit. |
medium-high |
| orchestrator.py:8796 | _readopt_running_agents registers ACTIVE for any running roboco-agent-{slug} container at startup, including a zombie from a prior orchestrator that already released the claim — blocks re-spawn until the stale container is noticed.536bbb64): _agent_holds_live_claim is now called for each running container; a container whose slug holds no non-terminal task is identified as a zombie and skipped (not registered ACTIVE) so the spawn gate can immediately re-dispatch. |
||
| orchestrator.py:9078 | _should_skip_live_reap spares any live container that is neither grok-wedged nor gateway-broken; a Claude agent alive but stuck in a non-verb loop keeps its claim forever.536bbb64): _maybe_kill_stuck_claude added as a third kill check — a non-GROK container with heartbeat stale past claude_stuck_kill_seconds (default 3600s) is now killed + evicted. Residual: a Claude agent stuck in a long verb loop (heartbeat still advancing via gateway calls) remains spared. |
||
| orchestrator.py:1105 | stop() calls stop_agent(release_claim=True) for every instance then _drain_bg_tasks; a respawn persist cancelled by the drain deadline leaves the durable count lagging in-memory (re-burn on next restart).536bbb64): _flush_respawn_tracker is called unbounded AFTER the bounded drain in stop(), so a drain-cancelled persist is overwritten by the flush before the process exits. |
||
| Fire-and-forget _bg_tasks persist ordering | orchestrator.py:4658 | _persist_respawn_record upsert is race-free but commits land in lock-acquisition order; if the lock isn't the first await at a future edit, a stale count could again win the durable row. |
low |
| Grok re-park retry_after back-off reset | orchestrator.py:7233 | _park_grok_rate_limited resets _grok_repark_count to 0 after a 25-min episode gap; a single slow re-park keeps the default 60s cycle — recovery latency is fine, but a borderline gap can flatten backoff mid-window. |
low |
| Human-only-role spawn skip drops a2a | orchestrator.py:10904 | _dispatch_a2a_work skips human-only notification targets; a future a2a request that expects a human-side action (CEO sign-off relay) is silently dropped, not surfaced. |
medium |
| Respawn-tracker durable restore evicts too eagerly | orchestrator.py:5561 | restore_respawn_tracker evicts rows whose task is terminal/missing; a task that transitioned terminal mid-restart (race) drops its strike count, so a still-wedged PM respawns from 0. |
low |
| Reaper live-skip falls back to Docker on registry miss | orchestrator.py:8597 | _assignee_container_running returns False on any inspect error (no docker binary / test ctx), so in a real-Docker failure the reaper releases a live agent's claim — mitigated by the instance-registry authoritative path. |
low |
Health
The orchestrator is the most behaviour-critical module in RoboCo and it shows: every race-prone path (respawn-tracker upsert, park-and-probe resume, readopt liveness, broken-gateway kill) carries an explicit docstring naming the live incident it prevents and the failure mode it degrades to, and the durable-state paths mirror the hardened WaitingRecord pattern (best-effort, can only suppress a spawn). Post-536bbb64, four previously medium risks are resolved: the park/probe revival race, the readopt zombie registration, the shutdown respawn-tracker re-burn, and the non-GROK stuck-agent blind spot (now caught by _maybe_kill_stuck_claude past 3600s). The residual exposure is the strategy-engine failure alert threshold (a misconfigured assess() could still silently fail for up to _STRATEGY_FAIL_CEO_NOTIFY_THRESHOLD ticks before surfacing) and the restart-window race where a terminal transition landing mid-restore drops a strike count. Net: integrity is high and well-instrumented.