"""Tier 1 — spec self-tests. Fast (no DB, no network).""" from __future__ import annotations from types import SimpleNamespace from typing import Any from uuid import uuid4 import pytest from roboco.foundation import _validate_lifecycle as _validate from roboco.foundation._validate_lifecycle import reachable_from from roboco.foundation.policy import lifecycle as spec from roboco.foundation.policy.lifecycle import _INTENT_VERBS, IntentSpec from roboco.models.base import TaskType as ModelTaskType def test_role_enum_has_every_pre_gateway_role() -> None: """Every role from PERMISSIONS.md must be enumerated. The canonical Role enum is now defined in `roboco.foundation.identity` and re-exported here. It includes the 9 pre-gateway roles plus the SYSTEM sentinel used for orchestrator-generated rows. The pre-gateway PERMISSIONS.md is the historical canon — SYSTEM is the post-foundation addition that doesn't appear in policy tables. """ expected = { "developer", "qa", "documenter", "cell_pm", "main_pm", "product_owner", "head_marketing", "auditor", "prompter", # post-gateway intake role (human-only, drafts tasks) "secretary", # CEO's chief-of-staff (human-only, gated CEO authority) "ceo", "system", } actual = {r.value for r in spec.Role} assert actual == expected, f"Role enum drift: {actual ^ expected}" def test_status_enum_has_every_pre_gateway_status() -> None: """Every status from STATUS_TRANSITIONS.md must be enumerated.""" expected = { "backlog", "pending", "claimed", "in_progress", "blocked", "paused", "verifying", "awaiting_qa", "needs_revision", "awaiting_documentation", "awaiting_pm_review", "awaiting_ceo_approval", "completed", "cancelled", } actual = {s.value for s in spec.Status} assert actual == expected, f"Status enum drift: {actual ^ expected}" def test_task_type_enum_matches_models() -> None: """The spec's TaskType must match the existing models.base.TaskType. If the existing model adds/removes a type, the spec must be updated in lockstep — that's the entire point of this module. """ spec_values = {t.value for t in spec.TaskType} model_values = {t.value for t in ModelTaskType} assert spec_values == model_values, ( f"TaskType drift between lifecycle.spec and models.base: " f"{spec_values ^ model_values}" ) def test_decision_allow_has_no_rejection_kind() -> None: d = spec.Decision.allow() assert d.allowed is True assert d.rejection_kind is None assert d.message is None assert d.missing == [] assert d.remediate is None def test_decision_reject_requires_rejection_kind() -> None: d = spec.Decision.reject( kind="not_authorized", message="role 'developer' may not call delegate", remediate="only PMs delegate; call give_me_work() instead", ) assert d.allowed is False assert d.rejection_kind == "not_authorized" assert d.message == "role 'developer' may not call delegate" assert d.remediate == "only PMs delegate; call give_me_work() instead" def test_decision_tracing_gap_carries_missing_list() -> None: d = spec.Decision.tracing_gap( missing=["plan", "journal:decision"], remediate="provide plan and a journal:decision entry", ) assert d.allowed is False assert d.rejection_kind == "tracing_gap" assert d.missing == ["plan", "journal:decision"] assert d.remediate == "provide plan and a journal:decision entry" def test_decision_tracing_gap_defensively_copies_missing() -> None: """tracing_gap must isolate the stored list from the caller's source.""" src = ["plan"] d = spec.Decision.tracing_gap(missing=src, remediate="r") src.append("mutated") assert d.missing == ["plan"] def test_decision_invariants_enforced_at_construction() -> None: """allowed=True ⇒ rejection_kind None; allowed=False ⇒ kind set.""" with pytest.raises(ValueError, match="allowed=True requires rejection_kind=None"): spec.Decision( allowed=True, rejection_kind="not_authorized", message="x", missing=[], remediate="x", ) with pytest.raises(ValueError, match="allowed=False requires rejection_kind"): spec.Decision( allowed=False, rejection_kind=None, message="x", missing=[], remediate="x", ) def test_decision_invariant_rejects_allowed_with_missing_or_remediate() -> None: """allowed=True with missing or remediate set raises (Fix 1 lock-in).""" with pytest.raises( ValueError, match="allowed=True requires missing=\\[\\] and remediate=None" ): spec.Decision( allowed=True, rejection_kind=None, message=None, missing=["plan"], remediate=None, ) with pytest.raises( ValueError, match="allowed=True requires missing=\\[\\] and remediate=None", ): spec.Decision( allowed=True, rejection_kind=None, message=None, missing=[], remediate="oops", ) def test_precondition_check_returns_bool() -> None: """A Precondition.check() is the gate-table evaluator.""" p = spec.Precondition( key="commits>=1", check=lambda task, _agent, _ctx: bool(getattr(task, "commits", None)), remediate="commit at least once before opening a PR", missing_token="commits>=1", ) task_with = SimpleNamespace(commits=["abc"]) task_without = SimpleNamespace(commits=[]) assert p.check(task_with, None, None) is True assert p.check(task_without, None, None) is False def test_action_spec_holds_role_status_and_precondition_data() -> None: a = spec.ActionSpec( name="claim", allowed_roles=frozenset({spec.Role.DEVELOPER}), source_statuses=frozenset({spec.Status.PENDING, spec.Status.NEEDS_REVISION}), target_status=spec.Status.CLAIMED, allowed_task_types=None, preconditions=(), self_review_block=False, needs_team_match=True, ) assert a.name == "claim" assert spec.Role.DEVELOPER in a.allowed_roles assert a.target_status == spec.Status.CLAIMED def test_intent_spec_composes_atomic_actions() -> None: i = spec.IntentSpec( name="i_will_work_on", allowed_roles=frozenset({spec.Role.DEVELOPER}), description="Claim a task and start work on it.", composes=("claim", "set_plan", "start"), extra_preconditions=(), side_effects=(), next_hint=lambda _t: "edit + commit, then open_pr", ) assert i.composes == ("claim", "set_plan", "start") assert i.next_hint(None) == "edit + commit, then open_pr" def test_status_transition_carries_role_constraint_optional() -> None: t = spec.StatusTransition( source=spec.Status.AWAITING_QA, target=spec.Status.AWAITING_DOCUMENTATION, triggered_by_action="qa_pass", role_constraint=frozenset({spec.Role.QA}), ) assert t.source == spec.Status.AWAITING_QA assert t.target == spec.Status.AWAITING_DOCUMENTATION assert t.triggered_by_action == "qa_pass" assert t.role_constraint == frozenset({spec.Role.QA}) def test_status_transitions_includes_dev_path() -> None: """The dev happy path: pending → claimed → in_progress → verifying → awaiting_qa.""" sources = {(t.source, t.target) for t in spec._STATUS_TRANSITIONS} assert (spec.Status.PENDING, spec.Status.CLAIMED) in sources assert (spec.Status.CLAIMED, spec.Status.IN_PROGRESS) in sources assert (spec.Status.IN_PROGRESS, spec.Status.VERIFYING) in sources assert (spec.Status.VERIFYING, spec.Status.AWAITING_QA) in sources def test_status_transitions_includes_qa_paths() -> None: sources = {(t.source, t.target) for t in spec._STATUS_TRANSITIONS} assert (spec.Status.AWAITING_QA, spec.Status.CLAIMED) in sources # QA claims assert (spec.Status.AWAITING_QA, spec.Status.AWAITING_DOCUMENTATION) in sources assert (spec.Status.AWAITING_QA, spec.Status.NEEDS_REVISION) in sources def test_status_transitions_includes_ceo_paths() -> None: sources = {(t.source, t.target) for t in spec._STATUS_TRANSITIONS} assert (spec.Status.AWAITING_PM_REVIEW, spec.Status.COMPLETED) in sources assert ( spec.Status.AWAITING_PM_REVIEW, spec.Status.AWAITING_CEO_APPROVAL, ) in sources assert (spec.Status.AWAITING_CEO_APPROVAL, spec.Status.COMPLETED) in sources assert (spec.Status.AWAITING_CEO_APPROVAL, spec.Status.NEEDS_REVISION) in sources # A blocked task the PM cannot resolve can also be surfaced to the CEO. assert (spec.Status.BLOCKED, spec.Status.AWAITING_CEO_APPROVAL) in sources def test_status_transitions_includes_block_pause_paths() -> None: sources = {(t.source, t.target) for t in spec._STATUS_TRANSITIONS} assert (spec.Status.IN_PROGRESS, spec.Status.BLOCKED) in sources assert (spec.Status.IN_PROGRESS, spec.Status.PAUSED) in sources assert (spec.Status.BLOCKED, spec.Status.IN_PROGRESS) in sources assert (spec.Status.PAUSED, spec.Status.IN_PROGRESS) in sources def test_every_non_terminal_status_can_be_cancelled() -> None: """PERMISSIONS.md says PM/CEO can cancel from any state.""" cancellable = { t.source for t in spec._STATUS_TRANSITIONS if t.target == spec.Status.CANCELLED } non_terminal = set(spec.Status) - {spec.Status.COMPLETED, spec.Status.CANCELLED} assert non_terminal <= cancellable, ( f"Statuses missing a cancel transition: {non_terminal - cancellable}" ) def test_status_graph_lookup_returns_targets() -> None: """STATUS_GRAPH is a quick `source -> {targets}` lookup.""" assert spec.Status.CLAIMED in spec.STATUS_GRAPH[spec.Status.PENDING] assert spec.Status.AWAITING_QA in spec.STATUS_GRAPH[spec.Status.VERIFYING] assert spec.STATUS_GRAPH[spec.Status.COMPLETED] == frozenset() def test_status_transitions_role_constraints_match_canon() -> None: """role_constraint must encode the per-row role gates from PERMISSIONS.md / STATUS_TRANSITIONS.md exactly. Tests that look only at (source, target) pairs miss role-typo regressions; this test pins the gates explicitly. """ by_pair = { (t.source, t.target, t.triggered_by_action): t.role_constraint for t in spec._STATUS_TRANSITIONS } # QA is the only role that can claim awaiting_qa assert by_pair[ (spec.Status.AWAITING_QA, spec.Status.CLAIMED, "claim") ] == frozenset({spec.Role.QA}) # Documenter is the only role that can claim awaiting_documentation assert by_pair[ (spec.Status.AWAITING_DOCUMENTATION, spec.Status.CLAIMED, "claim") ] == frozenset({spec.Role.DOCUMENTER}) # qa_pass / qa_fail: QA only assert by_pair[ (spec.Status.AWAITING_QA, spec.Status.AWAITING_DOCUMENTATION, "qa_pass") ] == frozenset({spec.Role.QA}) assert by_pair[ (spec.Status.AWAITING_QA, spec.Status.NEEDS_REVISION, "qa_fail") ] == frozenset({spec.Role.QA}) # docs_complete: documenter only assert by_pair[ ( spec.Status.AWAITING_DOCUMENTATION, spec.Status.AWAITING_PM_REVIEW, "docs_complete", ) ] == frozenset({spec.Role.DOCUMENTER}) # PM complete: cell + main PM (not board, not CEO) assert by_pair[ (spec.Status.AWAITING_PM_REVIEW, spec.Status.COMPLETED, "complete") ] == frozenset({spec.Role.CELL_PM, spec.Role.MAIN_PM}) # escalate_to_ceo: main_pm + product_owner + head_marketing — from a # completed review and from a blocked task, same role gate. escalate_roles = frozenset( { spec.Role.MAIN_PM, spec.Role.PRODUCT_OWNER, spec.Role.HEAD_MARKETING, } ) assert ( by_pair[ ( spec.Status.AWAITING_PM_REVIEW, spec.Status.AWAITING_CEO_APPROVAL, "escalate_to_ceo", ) ] == escalate_roles ) assert ( by_pair[ ( spec.Status.BLOCKED, spec.Status.AWAITING_CEO_APPROVAL, "escalate_to_ceo", ) ] == escalate_roles ) # CEO actions: CEO only assert by_pair[ (spec.Status.AWAITING_CEO_APPROVAL, spec.Status.COMPLETED, "ceo_approve") ] == frozenset({spec.Role.CEO}) assert by_pair[ (spec.Status.AWAITING_CEO_APPROVAL, spec.Status.NEEDS_REVISION, "ceo_reject") ] == frozenset({spec.Role.CEO}) # Cancel: PM + CEO from any non-terminal status cancel_constraint = frozenset({spec.Role.CELL_PM, spec.Role.MAIN_PM, spec.Role.CEO}) for src in spec.Status: if src in (spec.Status.COMPLETED, spec.Status.CANCELLED): continue assert by_pair[(src, spec.Status.CANCELLED, "cancel")] == cancel_constraint, ( f"cancel from {src.value} has wrong role_constraint" ) def test_atomic_action_table_has_pre_gateway_actions() -> None: """Every task tool from PERMISSIONS.md must have an ActionSpec.""" expected = { "activate", "claim", "start", "set_plan", "block", "unblock", "pause", "resume", "submit_verification", "submit_qa", "qa_pass", "qa_fail", "docs_complete", "complete", "submit_pm_review", "escalate_to_ceo", "ceo_approve", "ceo_reject", "cancel", "create_subtask", } assert expected <= set(spec._ATOMIC_ACTIONS), ( f"Missing ActionSpec entries: {expected - set(spec._ATOMIC_ACTIONS)}" ) def test_claim_action_allows_developer_from_pending() -> None: a = spec._ATOMIC_ACTIONS["claim"] assert spec.Role.DEVELOPER in a.allowed_roles assert spec.Status.PENDING in a.source_statuses assert a.target_status == spec.Status.CLAIMED def test_qa_pass_self_review_blocks() -> None: """A QA cannot qa_pass a task they themselves committed to.""" assert spec._ATOMIC_ACTIONS["qa_pass"].self_review_block is True assert spec._ATOMIC_ACTIONS["qa_fail"].self_review_block is True assert spec._ATOMIC_ACTIONS["docs_complete"].self_review_block is True def test_claim_rules_match_pre_gateway_table() -> None: """PERMISSIONS.md "What Each Role Can Claim From" — exact match. PMs claim from PENDING only; BACKLOG → PENDING is a separate `activate` action (strict transitions; no implicit activate-on-claim). """ assert spec.CLAIM_RULES[spec.Role.DEVELOPER] == frozenset( {spec.Status.PENDING, spec.Status.NEEDS_REVISION} ) assert spec.CLAIM_RULES[spec.Role.QA] == frozenset({spec.Status.AWAITING_QA}) assert spec.CLAIM_RULES[spec.Role.DOCUMENTER] == frozenset( {spec.Status.PENDING, spec.Status.AWAITING_DOCUMENTATION} ) assert spec.CLAIM_RULES[spec.Role.CELL_PM] == frozenset({spec.Status.PENDING}) assert spec.CLAIM_RULES[spec.Role.MAIN_PM] == frozenset({spec.Status.PENDING}) def test_team_rules_pin_team_for_seeded_agents() -> None: assert spec.ROLE_TEAM_RULES["be-dev-1"] == "backend" assert spec.ROLE_TEAM_RULES["be-pm"] == "backend" assert spec.ROLE_TEAM_RULES["fe-qa"] == "frontend" assert spec.ROLE_TEAM_RULES["main-pm"] is None # cross-cell def test_intent_verbs_table_has_every_gateway_verb() -> None: """Every gateway intent verb must have an IntentSpec.""" expected = { "give_me_work", "i_will_work_on", "i_will_plan", "delegate", "open_pr", "i_am_done", "i_am_blocked", "unclaim", "resume", "i_am_idle", "claim_review", "pass_review", "fail_review", "claim_doc_task", "i_documented", "complete", "escalate_up", "escalate_to_ceo", "submit_up", "unblock", "triage", "triage_all", } assert expected <= set(spec._INTENT_VERBS), ( f"Missing IntentSpec entries: {expected - set(spec._INTENT_VERBS)}" ) def test_i_will_work_on_composes_claim_set_plan_start() -> None: iv = spec._INTENT_VERBS["i_will_work_on"] assert iv.composes == ("claim", "set_plan", "start") assert spec.Role.DEVELOPER in iv.allowed_roles def test_i_will_plan_composes_claim_set_plan_start() -> None: """PMs use i_will_plan; the composition mirrors i_will_work_on.""" iv = spec._INTENT_VERBS["i_will_plan"] assert iv.composes == ("claim", "set_plan", "start") assert iv.allowed_roles == frozenset({spec.Role.CELL_PM, spec.Role.MAIN_PM}) def test_i_am_done_composes_submit_verification_then_submit_qa() -> None: iv = spec._INTENT_VERBS["i_am_done"] assert iv.composes == ("submit_verification", "submit_qa") def test_open_pr_has_git_side_effects() -> None: """open_pr is a side-effect-only verb (no DB transition).""" iv = spec._INTENT_VERBS["open_pr"] assert "push_branch" in iv.side_effects assert "create_pr" in iv.side_effects assert iv.composes == () # pure side effect verb def test_delegate_composes_create_subtask() -> None: iv = spec._INTENT_VERBS["delegate"] assert iv.composes == ("create_subtask",) assert iv.allowed_roles == frozenset({spec.Role.CELL_PM, spec.Role.MAIN_PM}) _STUB_TASK_DEFAULTS: dict[str, Any] = { "status": "pending", "task_type": "code", "commits": [], "plan": None, "assigned_to": None, "pr_number": None, } def _stub_task(**overrides: Any) -> SimpleNamespace: fields = {**_STUB_TASK_DEFAULTS, **overrides} fields["commits"] = fields["commits"] or [] return SimpleNamespace(**fields) def test_can_claim_developer_pending_allowed() -> None: d = spec.can_claim(spec.Role.DEVELOPER, _stub_task(status="pending")) assert d.allowed is True def test_can_claim_developer_completed_rejected() -> None: d = spec.can_claim(spec.Role.DEVELOPER, _stub_task(status="completed")) assert d.allowed is False assert d.rejection_kind == "invalid_state" def test_can_claim_developer_awaiting_qa_rejected() -> None: """Devs cannot claim awaiting_qa - that's QA's path.""" d = spec.can_claim(spec.Role.DEVELOPER, _stub_task(status="awaiting_qa")) assert d.allowed is False assert d.rejection_kind == "not_authorized" def test_can_invoke_intent_developer_can_call_i_will_work_on() -> None: d = spec.can_invoke_intent( spec.Role.DEVELOPER, "i_will_work_on", _stub_task(status="pending"), context=spec.Context(plan="my plan"), ) assert d.allowed is True def test_can_invoke_intent_pm_cannot_call_i_will_work_on() -> None: """PMs use i_will_plan; i_will_work_on is dev-only.""" d = spec.can_invoke_intent( spec.Role.CELL_PM, "i_will_work_on", _stub_task(status="pending"), context=spec.Context(plan="x"), ) assert d.allowed is False assert d.rejection_kind == "not_authorized" def test_can_invoke_intent_developer_open_pr_no_commits_tracing_gap() -> None: """open_pr requires >=1 commit. Without one -> tracing_gap.""" d = spec.can_invoke_intent( spec.Role.DEVELOPER, "open_pr", _stub_task(status="in_progress", commits=[]), context=spec.Context(), ) assert d.allowed is False assert d.rejection_kind == "tracing_gap" assert "commits>=1" in d.missing def test_valid_next_verbs_developer_in_progress_includes_open_pr_and_i_am_done() -> ( None ): verbs = spec.valid_next_verbs(spec.Role.DEVELOPER, _stub_task(status="in_progress")) assert "open_pr" in verbs assert "i_am_done" in verbs assert "i_am_blocked" in verbs def test_valid_next_verbs_pm_pending_includes_i_will_plan() -> None: verbs = spec.valid_next_verbs(spec.Role.CELL_PM, _stub_task(status="pending")) assert "i_will_plan" in verbs def test_composed_actions_for_returns_intent_composition() -> None: assert spec.composed_actions_for("i_will_work_on") == ("claim", "set_plan", "start") assert spec.composed_actions_for("open_pr") == () def test_intents_for_role_returns_role_scoped_verbs() -> None: dev_verbs = spec.intents_for_role(spec.Role.DEVELOPER) assert "i_will_work_on" in dev_verbs assert "open_pr" in dev_verbs assert "i_am_done" in dev_verbs assert "delegate" not in dev_verbs # PM only assert "claim_review" not in dev_verbs # QA only def test_status_after_returns_target_status() -> None: assert spec.status_after("claim", spec.Status.PENDING) == spec.Status.CLAIMED assert ( spec.status_after("submit_qa", spec.Status.VERIFYING) == spec.Status.AWAITING_QA ) assert ( spec.status_after("set_plan", spec.Status.IN_PROGRESS) is None ) # no transition def test_can_invoke_intent_open_pr_passes_when_owner_with_commits() -> None: """Green path for open_pr: owner + commits + no prior PR → allow.""" owner_id = uuid4() task = _stub_task( status="in_progress", commits=["abc"], pr_number=None, assigned_to=owner_id, ) d = spec.can_invoke_intent( spec.Role.DEVELOPER, "open_pr", task, context=spec.Context(actor_id=owner_id), ) assert d.allowed is True, f"expected allow, got {d}" def test_can_invoke_intent_open_pr_rejects_non_owner() -> None: """Non-owner trying open_pr → tracing_gap with owns_task missing.""" owner_id = uuid4() intruder_id = uuid4() task = _stub_task( status="in_progress", commits=["abc"], pr_number=None, assigned_to=owner_id, ) d = spec.can_invoke_intent( spec.Role.DEVELOPER, "open_pr", task, context=spec.Context(actor_id=intruder_id), ) assert d.allowed is False assert d.rejection_kind == "tracing_gap" assert "owns_task" in d.missing # --------------------------------------------------------------------------- # Task 8 — self-consistency validators (`_validate.py`) # --------------------------------------------------------------------------- def test_validators_pass_on_real_spec() -> None: """Importing roboco.foundation.policy.lifecycle must not raise — module-level import IS the test. We additionally call the runner directly so a future refactor that detaches it from import doesn't silently skip the gate. """ _validate.run_all_lifecycle_validators() def test_every_status_reachable_from_pending() -> None: """Reachability — except CANCELLED is its own thing and BACKLOG predates pending.""" reachable = reachable_from(spec.Status.PENDING) expected_reachable = set(spec.Status) - {spec.Status.BACKLOG, spec.Status.CANCELLED} assert expected_reachable <= reachable, ( f"Unreachable from pending: {expected_reachable - reachable}" ) def test_every_intent_verb_composes_known_actions() -> None: """Every IntentSpec.composes must reference declared atomic actions.""" for name, iv in spec._INTENT_VERBS.items(): for action_name in iv.composes: assert action_name in spec._ATOMIC_ACTIONS, ( f"Intent '{name}' composes unknown action '{action_name}'" ) def test_self_review_symmetry() -> None: """If qa_pass blocks, qa_fail and docs_complete must too.""" qp = spec._ATOMIC_ACTIONS["qa_pass"].self_review_block qf = spec._ATOMIC_ACTIONS["qa_fail"].self_review_block dc = spec._ATOMIC_ACTIONS["docs_complete"].self_review_block assert qp == qf == dc, ( "self_review_block asymmetry between qa_pass/qa_fail/docs_complete" ) def test_run_all_validators_raises_on_unknown_intent_action( monkeypatch: pytest.MonkeyPatch, ) -> None: """If an IntentSpec.composes references a non-existent action, the validator must raise LifecycleSpecError. Pins the gate's actual behavior — without this test, refactors that move run_all_validators() out of the import path could silently disable the gate. """ iv = _INTENT_VERBS["delegate"] broken = IntentSpec( name=iv.name, allowed_roles=iv.allowed_roles, description=iv.description, composes=("create_subtask", "ZZZ_FAKE_ACTION_DOES_NOT_EXIST"), extra_preconditions=iv.extra_preconditions, side_effects=iv.side_effects, next_hint=iv.next_hint, ) patched_intents = dict(_INTENT_VERBS) patched_intents["delegate"] = broken monkeypatch.setattr( "roboco.foundation.policy.lifecycle._INTENT_VERBS", patched_intents ) with pytest.raises(_validate.LifecycleSpecError, match="ZZZ_FAKE_ACTION"): _validate.run_all_lifecycle_validators() def test_unmigrated_is_pinned() -> None: """The known-debt set; remove an entry once that consumer is migrated.""" assert ( frozenset( { "enforcement.task_lifecycle._LEGACY_OPERATIONAL_EDGES", "enforcement.task_lifecycle._LEGACY_ROLE_GATES", } ) == spec.UNMIGRATED )