* feat(a2a): deliver latest incoming message preview into the claim briefing
list_unread_a2a now carries last_message_preview (the latest message from the
OTHER agent, never the agent's own reply), fetched via a correlated subquery in
the same query — no N+1 on the per-verb briefing path.
* feat(a2a): read_a2a verb delivers unread message bodies to the agent
A2AService.get_unread_messages returns the caller's unread INCOMING messages
(never its own sends), marking exactly those rows read atomically so a message
arriving mid-call is preserved. Wired as the read_a2a content verb (route +
do_server tool + granted to every delivery role) — the content-bearing read the
A2A inbox lacked (read_messages only zeroed the counter).
* docs(rag): document read_a2a as the A2A content-read path
* fix(task): backlog activation no longer requires a discussion session
Removes the SessionTaskTable gate in activate() (and its dangling log field),
deletes _inherit_parent_session + its create() call, and drops the now-unused
SessionTaskTable import. Coordination rides task state; the session subsystem is
being retired. Tests updated to the new (no-session) behavior.
* fix(orchestrator): drop session sweep from _run_sweep
Removes the messaging import + sweep_timed_out_sessions call. That import sat
outside the try/except, so once messaging.py is deleted it would have killed the
entire sweep cascade (budget kill-switch, token rollups, retention, image prune,
superseded-PR reconcile). Notification sweep + all maintenance sweeps unchanged.
* release-manager --no-tags read-clone fix
* test: update evidence_repo unit test for a2a last_message_preview
* refactor(gateway): drop session propagation on delegate
Removes propagate_sessions_to_subtask from delegate(), the ChoreographerDeps
messaging field + property, and the ChoreographerDeps messaging arg in deps.py
(ContentActions messaging + import stay until the verbs are removed). Deletes the
propagation test; strips the now-invalid messaging kwarg from ChoreographerDeps
test builders.
* refactor(gateway): remove say/open_session/link_session/channels verbs
Removes the four channel/session verbs across content_actions (impls +
ContentActionsDeps.messaging), do_server (tools + registry), role_config (grants
+ _CHANNEL_DISCOVERY), do.py (routes), schemas/v1/do.py (request models), and
deps.py (MessagingService import + construction). Regenerates the prompt verb
tables. dm/notify/read_messages/read_a2a stay. Tests deleted/updated accordingly.
* uv.lock Upgrade
* refactor: remove conversation RAG indexing; Secretary announces via notification
Drops the CONVERSATIONS index (index_conversation, ConversationsIndexPlugin,
IndexType.CONVERSATIONS enum, IndexConversationParams, mentor.py type-label, the
messaging index hook) and its chunk-table manifest entries. The Secretary's
ANNOUNCE/RELAY_MESSAGE now fan out a BROADCAST notification to every agent's
inbox (NotificationService.broadcast) instead of posting to a dead channel.
* fix(panel): label RAG health error lines by subsystem
A red llm_error (e.g. the glm-5.2:cloud weekly-limit 429) rendered under
the 'Embedding: ok' header with no label, reading as an embedding failure.
Prefix each error line with LLM / Embedding / Vector store.
* refactor: remove channel/message reads from metrics, dashboard, git, events
MetricsService drops get_communication_volume + the MessageTable
message-count in get_agent_metrics (and the now-dead messages_sent_week
field). DashboardService drops get_channel_feeds/_compute_channel_status
and the message read in get_recent_activity (task activity kept);
get_auditor_metrics no longer reports communication_volume.
GitService's two primary-session-id helpers always return None now
(callers already treat None as "no primary session"). events/handlers.py
drops the SESSION_CLOSED/SESSION_TIMEOUT subscriptions + the
handle_session_boundary handler.
Forced follow-on: api/routes/dashboard.py + api/schemas/dashboard.py
dropped the now-dangling live_feeds/ChannelFeed surface and the
/metrics/communication route, which wrapped the removed service calls
directly (mypy would otherwise fail on the missing attributes).
* refactor: delete MessagingService + channel seeding
Edited db/__init__.py and services/__init__.py first (drop the unconditional
Channel/Group/Message/Session table + MessagingService re-exports), then
deleted services/messaging.py, then trimmed db/seed.py to only create_agents
(create_channels/create_channel_memberships/create_initial_messages gone).
Forced expansion: api/routes/{channels,groups,sessions,messages}.py import
roboco.services.messaging directly (not through the package __init__), as
does api/routes/tasks.py (the session-links embed on GET /tasks/{id} and the
GET /{id}/sessions route). Deleting messaging.py without addressing these
breaks `import roboco.api.app` immediately, since app.py eagerly imports all
route modules at startup. Since the 4 CRUD route files are 100%
MessagingService-backed with zero independent logic (and are wholesale
deletes in the plan's later API-routes task anyway), deleted them now +
unmounted from app.py/routes/__init__.py; tasks.py got the same surgical
trim its later task already specified (drop session-links embed +
TaskSessionLinkResponse/TaskResponse.sessions). This pulls a slice of that
later work forward — the routes/schemas for channels/groups/sessions/messages
still need their own pass, but their messaging-coupled parts are gone.
Verified with a full-suite collection sweep (12010 tests collected, zero
import errors) beyond the directly touched test dirs, given the expanded
blast radius.
* refactor: remove channel/session/message models, tables, and channel policy
Models: deleted channel.py/group.py/session.py/messaging.py wholesale
(zero external consumers besides the models/__init__.py re-export).
message.py surgically trimmed: removed MessageCreate (dead) and MessageEdit
(never instantiated; ExtractedMessage.edit_history retyped to
list[dict[str, Any]] to match how it's actually persisted — confirmed
ExtractedMessage was never written to any DB table, so MessageTable's
removal carries no functional risk to the kept extraction pipeline).
base.py: removed SessionStatus + ChannelType, kept MessageType. Also
removed the confirmed-dead channels_read/channels_write fields from
models/agent.py:AgentPermissions and models/dashboard.py:ChannelFeedData.
db/tables.py: deleted ChannelTable/GroupTable/SessionTable/SessionTaskTable/
MessageTable, TaskTable.session_links, and JournalEntryTable.session_id —
cascaded through models/journal.py, services/journal.py, and
api/schemas+routes/journals.py (22 plumbing sites).
foundation/policy/communications.py: removed the ChannelSpec/CHANNELS
catalog + TEAM_SCOPED_ROLES/_CELL_*/_AUDITOR_ONLY helpers, kept the
notification policy (Priority/parse_priority/NOTIFY_SENDER_ROLES/
ACK_REQUIRED_BY_TYPE). enforcement/channel_access.py deleted (confirmed
fully dead in production). agents_config.py: removed CHANNEL_ACCESS
(kept A2A_ALLOWED_PAIRS). seeds/initial_data.py: removed
DEFAULT_CHANNELS/CHANNEL_MEMBERSHIPS/AUDITOR_SILENT_ACCESS + the
never-consumed INITIAL_MESSAGES. config.py: removed
session_idle_timeout_seconds (zero consumers). exceptions.py: removed
dead ChannelError/ChannelAccessDeniedError/SessionClosedError.
Forced expansion beyond the original file list — ChannelType cascaded
into a live, mounted surface the plan didn't trace: agents_config.
CHANNEL_ACCESS -> services/permissions.py's channel-RBAC methods (not
models/permissions.py, which turned out to have no channel code at all)
-> two real endpoints in api/routes/stream.py (GET /permissions,
GET /permissions/channel/{name}) and two dependency factories in
api/deps.py. Removed the channel methods + fields, deleted the
channel-specific stream.py endpoint, deleted require_channel_read/write.
Also deleted api/schemas/{channels,sessions}.py (hard dependency on the
removed enums; already fully dead after the Task 10 route deletions) and
api/schemas/messages.py (a TYPE_CHECKING-only import of the deleted
MessageTable; likewise already fully dead) + its dedicated test file.
Test updates: test_permissions.py -14 channel tests (matches the planned
count exactly), test_communications.py / test_communications_consumers.py
split to keep only notification-policy coverage, test_exceptions.py -9,
test_deps.py -4, plus the journal/stream/foundation-smoke fallout. Also
fixed a pre-existing (Task 7) broken assertion in
test_foundation_phase3_smoke.py that inspected a `say()` method already
removed from ContentActions.
Verified: full-suite collection (11961 tests, zero import errors) and a
complete test run (11567 passed, 394 skipped, 0 failed) in addition to
the targeted suites.
* migration: drop channels/groups/sessions/session_tasks/messages + enum types
alembic/versions/060_drop_messaging.py: drop_column journal_entries.
session_id (sidesteps hardcoding the FK constraint name — verified
empirically against a live migrated DB that it's actually
fk_journal_entries_session_id_sessions, but drop_column doesn't care
either way); drop_table in FK order (messages -> session_tasks ->
sessions -> groups -> channels); DROP TABLE IF EXISTS chunks_conversations
(runtime-provisioned, not alembic-managed, would otherwise orphan); DROP
TYPE IF EXISTS for messagetype/sessionstatus/sessionscope/channeltype
(messagetype's Python enum stays for ExtractedMessage, but the DB type
had zero live columns left once MessageTable was dropped in the prior
commit). downgrade() raises NotImplementedError — one-way removal.
Pruned scripts/reset_runtime_state.sql + .sh: removed the DELETE/COUNT
lines for messages/session_tasks/sessions/groups/channels and the
groups.active_session_id reset block.
Verified end-to-end against a scratch Postgres DB: full migration chain
001->060 applies cleanly, alembic heads shows a single head, all 6 dropped
tables + 4 enum types + the journal_entries.session_id column are
confirmed gone, journal_entries keeps only its journal_id/task_id FKs,
downgrade correctly raises NotImplementedError without corrupting DB
state, and the pruned reset_runtime_state.sql runs clean (no errors)
against a fully-migrated DB.
* refactor(api): remove channel/session/message routes + WS streams
Most of this task's file list was already forced through in earlier
commits (routes/{channels,groups,sessions,messages}.py + app.py/__init__.py
unmounting in the MessagingService-deletion commit; tasks.py's
session-links embed + GET /{id}/sessions + schemas/tasks.py's
TaskResponse.sessions in that same commit; deps.py's require_channel_read/
write + schemas/{channels,sessions}.py in the models/tables commit). This
closes out what was left:
- api/websocket.py: deleted the channel_stream + session_stream routes,
ConnectionManager's channel_connections/session_connections dicts,
connect_channel/connect_session, broadcast_to_channel/broadcast_to_session,
get_channel_subscriber_count, and their cleanup lines in disconnect().
Agent streams, notification streams, and the operator system stream are
untouched.
- api/websocket_bridge.py: deleted _handle_session_event +
_handle_message_event and their SESSION_CREATED/SESSION_CLOSED/
SESSION_TIMEOUT/MESSAGE_SENT subscriptions. The A2A live-view, rate-limit,
usage, agent-lifecycle, and notification bridges are untouched.
- api/schemas/websocket.py: removed NewMessageBroadcast, WSMessageNew,
WSMessageEdit, WSMessageDelete, WSSessionClosed — kept the WSMessage base
class (still subclassed by the kept WSAgentStream/WSNotification) plus
those two.
- api/schemas/groups.py: deleted (already fully orphaned since routes/
groups.py was removed; its GroupResponse/GroupDetailResponse had zero
consumers).
Updated the 5 websocket test files accordingly (removed the channel/
session-specific tests + fixed imports); test_websocket_bridge.py's
registration-coverage test dropped the SESSION_*/MESSAGE_SENT assertions.
Verified: full-suite collection (11943 tests, zero import errors) and a
complete test run (11549 passed, 394 skipped, 0 failed).
* docs: retire channels/sessions/messages from agent-facing docs + CLAUDE.md
Rewrites docs/rag (RAG-indexed) + docs/map + CLAUDE.md to reflect A2A (dm +
read_a2a) as primary agent comms; deletes the channel docs, splits messaging-tools
+ messaging-notification (renamed notification.md), swaps the WS worked example to
A2A_MESSAGE_SENT. _complete_map.md still needs regeneration (generated file).
* refactor(panel): remove Communications surface (channels/sessions)
Deletes the /communications routes, message components, task-detail Sessions tab,
use-channels + channel/session WS hooks, and the channels/sessions/messages/groups
api clients; prunes the Channel/Session/Message/Group types + mock data. (Auditor
live-feeds + dashboard.ts dead-route cleanup is a follow-up.)
* refactor(panel): drop auditor channel-feed + dead communication-metric route
* docs(map): regenerate _complete_map from updated slices
* fix(a2a): reduce get_unread_messages complexity below xenon C + stale comments
Extract the per-conversation unread-counter recompute into _reset_unread_counter
(the CI quality gate flagged get_unread_messages as rank C). Also drop the deleted
open_session from a content_actions comment and reword an evidence_repo docstring
that cited the removed messaging._notify_mentions.
---------
Co-authored-by: Renn F <rennf93@users.noreply.github.com>
* release-manager: fencing-token mutex + executor/readiness hardening
Closes the release-mutex TTL race (#17, HIGH) and the remaining
release-manager gaps (#88, #89, #201, #202):
- #17: the release mutex is now acquired with a uuid4 fencing token and
released via Lua compare-and-del; a background asyncio heartbeat
compare-and-expires the TTL ~every 60s while the execute owns the lock,
so a live execute no longer expires and a crashed one auto-releases
<=3000s. A second approve after TTL expiry cannot usurp and rm -rf the
in-flight clone — the fenced first-finally keeps its lock.
- #89: a Redis outage during acquire stays fail-closed (the execute never
runs) but now returns a distinct redis_unavailable result + log so the
CEO sees the cause instead of a false already_in_progress.
- #88: commit_and_push RuntimeError is wrapped into a structured
ReleaseResult(commit_failed) instead of a 500.
- #201: first-release fallback still emits untracked version-ref files as
gaps (no longer silenced by the first-release branch).
- #202: _await_proc awaits proc.wait() after kill() so a timeout cannot
leak a zombie.
TDD: tests/unit/services/test_release_proposal_concurrency.py extends
_FakeRedis with eval/get/expire and pins the fencing/heartbeat/usurper
invariants + the redis_unavailable result.
* PM/code-task creation guard + main_pm coverage + issue carve-out
Closes the creation-time role x task_type gap (the user's explicit example)
and the main_pm delegate hole:
- New pure helper `pm_cannot_own_code(role, task_type, is_issue_resolution)`
in foundation/policy/batch.py — single source of truth. Both PM roles
(cell_pm + main_pm) coordinate; a `code` task assigned/claimed by a PM is
a structural mismatch, EXCEPT a PM taking a code task in needs_revision to
resolve review/QA issues directly (the carve-out).
- Creation-time guard: TaskService.create calls the helper (closes the
create-with-cell-PM-assignee hole the team-based check misses).
- Delegate path + spec claim gate consult the same helper.
`_validate_assignee_task_type` / `_task_type_hint_for` now key on the
Role (CELL_PM OR MAIN_PM), not the cell-PM slug set — closes the
delegate-to-main-pm-as-code hole.
- identity.role_for_uuid_or_none is None-tolerant (treats None as "not a
PM" and proceeds) so a malformed/missing assignee cannot crash the guard.
- prompter.create_task_from_draft reuses the guard at draft-create.
TDD: test_batch.py (helper matrix + carve-out), test_main_pm_code_guard.py
(main_pm coverage), test_delegate_assignee_task_type.py (delegate parity),
test_lifecycle_spec.py (claim gate: rejects PM claiming code from pending,
allows from needs_revision + PM claiming planning + dev claiming code).
* task-service: completion hooks + escalation/cancel/audit hardening
Closes the task-service cluster (#21/#98, #99, #100, #101, #103, #216; #102
verified already-covered, #217 verified already-guarded):
- #21/#98: ceo_approve now closes the work session + triggers completion
hooks before worktree removal (no-op when work_session_id is None), so a
CEO-approved task lands the same close-path as PM-completed.
- #99: apply_escalation routes through the transition validator with an
enumerated escalation exemption (_ESCALATABLE_TO_BLOCKED) instead of an
arbitrary source->BLOCKED write; BACKLOG is refused.
- #100: branchless ceo_reject awaiting_ceo_approval->pending gets a real
spec edge (ceo_reject_to_pool ActionSpec + _STATUS_TRANSITIONS entry) so
future admin-override tightening can't wedge the path.
- #101: revision_count bump is documented as the single chokepoint, with
the pre-block RESTORE path undoing it when restoring a snapshotted
needs_revision (same cycle resuming, not a new rejection).
- #103: cancel cascade surfaces non-terminal orphans instead of swallowing
the role violation.
- #216: _remove_task_worktree_on_terminal escalates recurring FS/permission
failure (audit/notify after N) instead of silent-failing forever.
- #102: pinned in test_verb_runner_midverb_invalid_state.py (committed with
the choreographer cluster) — verb-runner savepoints already surface a
concurrent mid-verb state change as INVALID_STATE.
- #217: submit_for_qa claimed_by guard verified intact.
TDD: test_task.py, test_worktree_cleanup_on_complete.py,
test_escalation_board_guard.py (#99), test_task_service_* integration,
test_lifecycle_spec.py.
* choreographer: gate-claim guards + pr-gate hardening + fail-open logging
Closes the choreographer cluster (#5/#222, #29, #30, #82, #188, #189,
#192; #157/#187 verified already-fixed/pinned; #102 pin lives here):
- #5/#222: the unchanged-PR guard's fail-open head_sha lookup now logs
(warning) on a slug-resolver/git-helper error so a regression cannot
silently turn the pr_fail re-submit loop-stopper into a no-op. Stays
fail-open (never wedges the PM).
- #29: pinned (REFUTED-with-pin) — _lane_claim_guard already returns the
error envelope without releasing the claim on a transient lookup error.
- #30: pinned (REFUTED-with-negative-pin) — a non-batch branchless main_pm
root cannot bypass the complete spec gate (is_batch_umbrella requires
batch_id set).
- #82: _post_gate_review_to_pr wraps the slug-resolution call in try/except
(mirrors _capture_pr_head_sha) so a malformed cell_map AttributeError no
longer 500s the reviewer after a committed gate transition.
- #188: _is_hand_formatted_verdict anchors the header regex to line-start,
so a quoted (> ## Summary) or inline (mid-prose) header mention no longer
false-refuses a hand-formatted verdict.
- #189: pr_fail re-captures the PR head SHA after the transition commits and
re-stamps the verdict note only when it advanced (closes the stale-SHA
false-allow loop-hole); no-advance stays a single note write.
- #192: claim_gate_review skips the dev claim guards (already_active/paused/
lane) via a new skip_dev_guards param — a pr_reviewer inspecting an
assembled PR does not start work, so the single-active-task / code-lane
invariants do not apply; the dependency guard is kept, and QA's
claim_review parity is preserved.
- #157/#187: verified in tree — pr_review-only handoff is intentionally
prior-work-worth-resuming; self_review_block wiring (reviewer != dev)
holds on assembled tasks with 4 existing pin tests.
TDD: test_choreographer_*, test_pr_gate_posts_review (#82),
test_pr_review_hand_format_guard (#188), test_submit_root_unchanged_pr_guard
(#189), test_claim_gate_review_guards (#192), test_verb_runner_midverb
_invalid_state (#102 pin).
* playbook curate: guard the gating commit against a poisoned session (#55)
The explicit `session.commit()` that gates the RAG index (commit-before-index
so an uncommitted playbook cannot land in the corpus) raised PendingRollbackError
when a prior mid-verb failure had rolled the caller's session back — 500ing the
whole curation verb instead of returning a clean envelope, and (worse) risking a
fall-through to index an uncommitted playbook. Wrap the commit: on
PendingRollbackError, log + return invalid_state with a re-fetch/retry remediate
and skip the index. The happy path still commits exactly once then indexes.
TDD: test_playbook_verbs.py — poisoned-session returns a clean invalid_state and
does NOT index; clean-session still commits once + indexes (pins no fail-closed
inversion / no double-commit).
* [chore] gateway: atomic activate merge — preserve probe_failures across re-park (#156)
activate() was a blind SET that reset probe_failures to 0, so a probe-failure
increment that just landed (or was in flight) could be wiped by a concurrent
re-park — resetting the give-up / CEO-notify count mid-episode. Route activate
through a server-side Lua merge (roboco:activate_rate_limit) that refreshes the
episode metadata (kind / activated_at / retry_after / affected_agents) while
carrying over the previous probe_failures count. Indivisible w.r.t. the
increment/reset scripts (Redis single-threads an EVAL).
#56 (notify to prompter/secretary refused) verified SAFE — the pin tests
(test_notify_rejects_prompter_recipient / _secretary_recipient /
_allows_ceo_recipient) already cover the only human notify target invariant;
no legitimate send is dropped, no code change.
* [chore] foundation/policy: spec gates + QA retry-key pin (Cluster F)
#50 sync_branch composes=() so the spec gate accepted a terminal/paused/
blocked task and the handler rebased a dead/parked branch — add a
PRECONDITION_SYNC_BRANCH_STATE (claimed/in_progress/verifying/needs_revision
only), rejection_kind=invalid_state. TDD: 28 spec tests.
#148 submit_root's prose asserts 'a Main-PM root is planning-typed, never
code' but only the creation path (main_pm_cannot_own_code) backed it — add
PRECONDITION_ROOT_NOT_CODE on the submit_root IntentSpec (defense in depth),
scoped to submit_root only so the shared submit_for_review action keeps
cell_pm+code submit_up parity. Graceful on Mock/None task_type so the
choreographer Mock-task tests don't crash. TDD: 2 spec tests.
#150 VERB_RETRY_LIMITS is keyed by the MCP-exposed names (pass/fail), not
the IntentSpec-internal pass_review/fail_review — already correct; add a
pin test so a one-sided rename can't silently drop the QA-handoff cap.
#142 main_pm_cannot_own_code/pm_cannot_own_code already normalize casing
(.lower()) — no-op, pin test test_main_pm_cannot_own_code_is_case_insensitive
already in tree.
* [chore] worksession-git: 405 merge-method fallback + non-destructive close (Cluster W)
#108 _merge_with_retry hardcoded 'squash' and raised MergeConflictError on a
405 with no method fallback — wedging the PM on an open, mergeable PR whose
repo merely had the squash button off. Add a 405 fallback to a permitted
method (via _first_allowed_merge_method, exclude='squash'), mirroring the CEO
merge_pull_request path. A 405 with no permitted fallback (or a second 405)
still falls through to the already-merged disambiguation / MergeConflictError.
TDD: 2 new tests (fallback-success, no-permitted-method-raises).
#109 close_pull_request defaulted delete_branch=True, so the choreographer
supersede path deleted a superseded PR's branch while the orchestrator
supersede path explicitly preserved it — the two disagreed, and the
destructive default ran on the 'close the dead PR' path where the branch may
still be referenced / useful for audit. Flip the default to False (opt-in
deletion) and make the choreographer caller explicit (parity with the
orchestrator). TDD: 1 new test (default preserves branch); existing
deletion-when-requested test now passes delete_branch=True explicitly.
Dispositions verified against current code (no silent drops):
- #27 REFUTED/FIXED-UNDEPLOYED: work_session.merge_pr resolves by session_id
(no global pr_number lookup); the real cross-repo collision fix
(project_id scoping on pr_merge/close_pull_request/rebase_pr_for_task/
pr_target) is already in tree + tested (test_pr_merge_scopes_task_lookup_
by_project_id, test_close_pull_request_scopes_task_lookup_by_project_id,
test_git_pr_target_scoping). Verify-only.
- #106 REFUTED: a guard exists (rev-list --count {base_ref}..{branch} == 0)
before reset --hard + base_ref falls back to default_branch; tests lock
the safety (test_create_branch_never_repoints_branch_with_real_work,
test_create_branch_does_not_reset_or_checkout_shared_clone).
- #218 BY-DESIGN: the merge_pr idempotent guard intentionally preserves the
audit trail (docstring + test_merge_pr_idempotent_on_already_completed_
preserves_audit_trail); a COMPLETED session always carries attribution
(COMPLETED only via merge_pr), so the NULL-COMPLETED case is unreachable.
- #104 BY-DESIGN: agents never merge to the repo default branch in RoboCo's
model (root→master is CEO-only); the guard is a correct CEO-only rail,
locked by test_pr_merge_into_default_branch_is_ceo_only.
* [chore] llm: surface disabled-provider downgrade + scrub probe log (#20/#3/#211)
#20/#3 resolve_for_agent silently fell through to the legacy Anthropic path
when a configured provider was disabled — indistinguishable from 'no
assignment', so the operator got no signal that spawns bypassed the
provider. Surface the bypass with a warning (graceful degradation stays the
default — a stalled spawn is worse than a routing miss) and add an opt-in
ROBOCO_ROUTING_STRICT (default-off) that fail-closes instead. Wired into the
panel Feature Flags card. TDD: 3 unit tests (warn-on-disabled, strict-raises,
no-assignment-stays-silent).
#211 probe_ollama_tags logged str(exc) raw on the generic-exception branch —
structured log could carry connection internals / stack traces. Log the
exception class name only. TDD: existing generic-branch test strengthened to
assert the log kwargs don't leak the raw text.
* [chore] support/stream/optimal/playbook/comms hardening (Cluster S)
Logical-gaps sweep, Cluster S (TDD, red→green per item):
#64 notification_delivery.acknowledge published the NOTIFICATION_ACKED bus
event directly (bypassing the outbox) — a rollback left a phantom ACK. Route
it through defer_bus_publish (after_commit), mirroring deliver.
#76 playbook.archive()/reject() stamped the archiver into approved_by/
approved_at, overwriting approval provenance (and fabricating approval for a
rejected draft). Add archived_by/archived_at (migration 053 + table + model)
and write those on archive/reject, leaving approval attribution intact.
#181 vector_store.replace_chunks wiped existing index rows even when every
chunk lacked an embedding (embedder failure). Skip the wipe when chunks is
non-empty but records is empty — preserve good rows for nothing.
#182/#183 optimal.record_learning recomputed a learn-{md5(full_content)}
tracking source that never matched the URI the plugin embedded chunks under
(roboco://learnings/{doc_id}, doc_id=lrn-{hash100}). Use the plugin's
returned doc_id so de-index/lookup-by-source finds the chunk rows.
#96/#97 transcription periodic flush only peeked ready buffers (unbounded
map growth) and ran sync callbacks on the event loop (a slow callback
blocked the flush task). Flush (remove) each ready buffer after notifying,
and offload each callback to a thread.
#212 _TEAM_SCOPED_ROLES was duplicated across communications/agents_config/
seeds. Single-source it in foundation.policy.communications; consumers
reference that object (identity-tested).
#19 stream_bus._dispatch_event re-ran already-succeeded handlers on a
recover_pending replay (duplicate side effects). Add a per-(event.id,
handler) SET-NX idempotency guard: skip on a hit, clear the key on handler
failure so a replay re-runs it, fail-open when redis is unavailable.
Dispositions (no code change): #77 approve() index-write pair asserted
BY-DESIGN; #62/#63 notification DB-dedup verified pinned; #184/#185 REFUTED;
#214 REFUTED; #215 BY-DESIGN.
* [chore] db/migrations: graph-integrity guard + conftest unreachable-DB warning (Cluster D)
Logical-gaps sweep, Cluster D (TDD + real alembic upgrade head verification):
#16/#37 add tests/unit/test_migration_graph_integrity.py — a static guard that
the alembic migration graph has exactly one head, every down_revision resolves,
every revision is reachable from a root, and no revision id is duplicated. The
suite builds its DB via Base.metadata.create_all (not alembic upgrade head), so
a forked head / dangling down_revision / duplicate id would otherwise ship
silently and break a real deploy mid-stream.
Caught a real bug in the process: migration 053's revision id
"053_playbook_archived_attribution" (33 chars) exceeded alembic's
alembic_version.version_num VARCHAR(32) — a fresh `alembic upgrade head` raised
"value too long for type character varying(32)" at the 053 stamp. Renamed to
"053_playbook_archived_attr" (26 chars). Verified end-to-end on a scratch PG:
upgrade head stamps 053, downgrade -1 returns to 052. (The pre-existing
test_every_migration_revision_id_fits_the_alembic_version_column guard is now
green too; it had been red on the 33-char id.)
#90 conftest silently pytest.skip'd every DB test when Postgres was unreachable
— a non-Docker box reported a green run of all-skips. Extract the warning into
_warn_if_pg_unavailable and fire it at import so the operator sees the DB is
down (the per-test skip path is unchanged). Test: warns when unavailable, silent
when reachable (verified under -W error::UserWarning).
Dispositions (verified against real code + a fresh alembic upgrade head, no code
change): #6 REFUTED — sa.Enum(create_type=False) at 001:119/304 does NOT break a
fresh upgrade head (001→052 applied cleanly on a scratch DB); #8 REFUTED — the
upgrade passed 030/031 (RAG chunk tables) without pgvector installed; pgvector is
a runtime concern handled by roboco/db/base.py, not a migration prerequisite;
#40 REFUTED — the `|| echo` mask was already removed and partial-schema drift
reports exit 1 (only by-design unreachable/unmigrated skips remain); #204 REFUTED
— the property walk seed IS pinned (random.Random(20260504), line 97); #205/#206
REFUTED — the smoke-trace fixture IS wired via
test_lifecycle_smoke_replay.py (8 passed); no shell smoke scripts exist in the
tree to wire; #137 BY-DESIGN — pyproject version 0.14.0 is an operational note,
no code gate.
* [chore] panel: admin-override force flag + kanban subtask_count + ws cleanup + ui-store dedupe (Cluster P)
#13: kanban admin-override into a hatch state (completed / awaiting_qa /
awaiting_pm_review) now requires an explicit force=true from the panel and
emits a dedicated task.admin_override audit row server-side; non-hatch
overrides need no force. Backend gate in tasks route + admin_set_status;
panel kanban-board sends force for hatch targets; TaskUpdate carries force.
#198: kanban service threads the real subtask_count (one grouped query) into
dev + priority-swimlane + main-pm-flat boards instead of a hardcoded 0.
#79: useWebSocket cleanup clears messages/lastMessage/state on unmount or
endpoint change so a dep-change (navigating to another stream) can't leak the
prior subscription's stale snapshot as live.
#186: disambiguate the duplicate ui-store modules -- the session/scroll store
in lib/stores renamed to useScrollRestorationStore / scroll-restoration-store
(barrel + 2 consumers updated); the sidebar/theme useUIStore in @/store is now
the sole useUIStore.
#12: verified already in-tree (release-proposal-card surfaces non-404 errors
with retry; getProposal maps only 404->null). #80 by-design (handleTransportError
already resets isSending on a no-payload SSE drop). #81 docs (streamUrl docstring
records that live-intake SSE auth is session-id-based bearer-style).
Backend: ruff+mypy clean, 278 tests green. Panel: lint+typecheck clean, 159 tests.
* orchestrator: park/reaper/readopt/a2a hardening + self-heal/ci-watch dedupe (Cluster O)
Closes the orchestrator-side logical gaps from the sweep:
- #75 a2a human-only drop surfaced: _dispatch_a2a_work logs the skip
("a2a request targets a human-only role; left as a notification for the
human (not spawned)") instead of silently dropping the target — the
CEO/secretary/prompter still see the notification; only the spawn is
suppressed. (orchestrator.py)
- #72 readopt liveness: _readopt_running_agents requires a non-stale live
claim (via _agent_holds_live_claim) and skips a zombie container so a
reaped-but-restart-readopted agent isn't double-counted as active.
- #74 shutdown drain: stop() calls _flush_respawn_tracker so the durable
respawn counter write-throughs aren't lost on a clean stop.
- #71 resolve_wait active-guard + deferred liveness: a rate_limit_lifted
WaitingRecord is only confirmed-live after a _confirm_resume_liveness
probe (deferred deletion _resume_confirm_delay=30.0), and an
already-active agent short-circuits the repark. Scoped to
rate_limit_lifted records (the only ones at risk of a false lift).
- #73 stuck-Claude kill: _maybe_kill_stuck_claude + _claude_stuck_kill_ttl
(config.claude_stuck_kill_seconds) — a live container whose heartbeat is
stale past the grace AND whose gateway probe is broken is killed+evicted,
not protected forever by the reaper's live-skip.
- #230 verified FIXED-UNDEPLOYED: _gateway_broken_past_grace already
requires N consecutive false-broken probes (not one flaky streak); no
change, test added to pin the N-consecutive invariant.
- #43 self-heal per-observation dedupe: a fingerprint collapses repeat
CEO notifications for the same CI regression.
- #44 ci_watch dedupe by (git_url, workflow): a monorepo's multiple
workflows each get their own fix task (was collapsed by git_url alone).
- #49 identity.role_for_slug_or_none None-hardening: a stale/malformed
slug resolves to None and the human-only skip falls through to the safe
"not spawnable" path instead of crashing.
- #193 strategy engine: notify the CEO on a persistent assess failure
instead of failing silently in the background loop.
TDD: test_no_spawn_human_roles (a2a skip surfaced), test_orchestrator_
shutdown_drain (#74), test_provider_overload_break (#71), test_readopt_
running_agents (#72), test_resolve_wait_repark (#71), test_stale_claim_
reaper (#73/#230), test_strategy_engine_loop (#193, new),
test_self_heal_engine (#43), test_ci_watch_engine (#44), test_identity
(#49). All red->green.
* chore: make-quality green — xenon complexity refactors + mypy test fixes + lifecycle regen
No behavior changes. Brings the tree to a fully green `make quality` (the
base branch never passed the xenon B-rank gate on several blocks; the
lifecycle artifacts had drifted from the committed ceo_reject_to_pool edge).
Xenon B-rank refactors (extract a helper; preserve semantics exactly):
- api/routes/tasks.py: _apply_forced_status_override + _StatusOverride
dataclass bundle (update_task override block).
- services/task.py: _enforce_no_pm_code_on_create (create guards) +
_escalation_diverts_to_pool (collapses the two board/advisory +
main_pm+code divert branches into one predicate).
- services/prompter.py: _coerce_pm_code_to_planning (create_task_from_draft).
- services/notification.py: _duplicate_unacked_exists (_create_notification
purpose-based dedup query + ACK_REQUIRED_BY_TYPE gate).
- services/sequencing.py: _same_assignee_lane_edges (the undeclared-surface
same-assignee lane fallback at the tail of dev_task_collision_edges).
- gateway/choreographer/_impl.py: _pm_task_type_error static helper
(_validate_assignee_task_type compound PM guard).
- gateway/choreographer/pr_gate.py: _gate_review_event_verdict +
_gate_review_body static helpers (_post_gate_review_to_pr).
mypy test fixes (no type:ignore — banned; use typing.cast with quoted
strings per TC006):
- test_task_update_completeness: TaskUpdate(acceptance_criteria=None).
- test_bus: cast("Redis", _FakeRedis()); Redis import under TYPE_CHECKING.
- test_pr_merge_concurrency: capture AsyncMocks into locals before asserting.
- test_notification_delivery_phantom: cast("UUID", to_agents[0]).
Lifecycle artifact regen (owed from Cluster T #100 — the
awaiting_ceo_approval -> pending `ceo_reject_to_pool` edge was added to the
spec in 3d633084 without regenerating the derived artifacts the
foundation-check gate diffs against): docs/rag/lifecycle/intent-verbs.md,
docs/rag/lifecycle/status-transitions.md, panel/lib/lifecycle.json.
services/kanban.py: ruff format only (collapses the _load_subtask_counts
signature that drifted unformatted from Cluster P).
* [chore] logical-gaps sweep — Cluster I (intake/product/pitch)
#57/#58 prompter: preserve a top-level product_id with a 1-cell map
(prompter.py create_task_from_draft — top-level target wins over a
redundant 1-cell map instead of dropping product_id); reject — not
silently skip — a malformed project_id in the_work cell entries
(prompter.py _draft_cell_map raises ValidationError).
#59/#159 prompter: create_task_from_draft now operates on a copy
(_copy_draft) so _validate_and_coerce_draft / _clean_list never mutate
the caller's draft dict.
#160 prompter: _resolve_owning_team consults product/board routing
before forcing MAIN_PM on a multi-cell map (product root stays Board,
product+assignee-is-board stays Board).
#83/#84 github_provisioning: create_repo is idempotent by GitHub name
— a 422 "name already exists" (orphaned repo from a rolled-back prior
approval) is fetched and reused instead of erroring; pitch re-approval
now reuses the orphaned repo end-to-end.
#196 kanban: flat main-PM board has a "coordination" column for
non-cell teams (MAIN_PM/Board) instead of dropping their cards.
#197 project update: an explicit null in the PATCH body now clears the
stored field, distinct from an absent field (leave unchanged).
ProjectService.update drops exclude_none so explicit-None applies; the
PATCH route uses ProjectUpdate.model_validate(data.model_dump(
exclude_unset=True)) to preserve the request's unset-tracking (the old
field-by-field construction marked every field set and defeated the
distinction — nulling NOT-NULL git_url).
TDD: prompter 47, github_provisioning+pitch 16, kanban+project 67,
project routes 37 — all green; ruff + mypy clean.
* [chore] logical-gaps sweep — Cluster M (mcp-servers)
#60 flow_server/do_server: the circuit-breaker substitution no longer
erases the fixable rejection — the original envelope (kind/message/
remediate) is nested as inner on a copy of the SDK's circuit_open
envelope (the SDK dict is not mutated in place). The agent still sees
WHY the verb failed, not just that the breaker tripped.
#61 flow_server/do_server: a 404 carrying a *descriptive* detail
(not FastAPI's bare default {"detail":"Not Found"}) is now a
real resource not_found, surfaced as not_found so the agent
re-fetches state — instead of a misleading "server-side wiring gap"
invalid_state. The bare default and unparseable 404s still synthesize
the wiring-gap envelope; a 404 with a real Envelope (error field)
is still surfaced as-is.
#161 flow_server/do_server: dict error.code classification now uses
an exact-code map (authoritative for the codes the handlers emit) with
a substring fallback for unknown codes. Fixes the real regression:
AUTHENTICATION_REQUIRED carries no AUTHORIZED/DENIED/PERMISSION
substring, so the old substring-only rule dropped it to invalid_state
instead of not_authorized — an auth storm attributed as a state storm.
The fallback also adds AUTH so future AUTH-prefixed codes classify.
#162 flow_server/do_server: _register_tools gains a
ROBOCO_ALLOW_FULL_TOOLSET env override (default-off) so a missing
manifest falls back to the full tool set instead of raising — a
dev/test escape hatch. Production fail-loud behaviour is unchanged.
#163 intake_server: propose_batch accepts name as well as
title (intake drafts in the wild have used both), normalizing a
name-only draft onto a copy as title (caller's dict never mutated),
and reports the dropped count + reason in the return instead of
silently vanishing malformed drafts. The empty-batch hint now names
name as an alternative.
TDD: 123 mcp_servers tests green (14 new + 2 updated); ruff + mypy clean.
* [chore] Cluster N — conventions/docs logical-gaps sweep
#33: _create_new_doc/_update_existing_doc now resolve via
_resolve_contained_path (the RAG-returned update path was not containment-
checked — an escaping source could write/overwrite outside the docs dir).
#34: _commit_doc_to_repo returns committed/skipped/failed instead of
swallowing all exceptions; surfaced on DocRef.commit_status, the write
response, and the docs MCP guidance so a failed repo commit is fail-loud.
#35: write_doc only updates the similar doc when its filename matches — a
different filename creates a new file instead of collapsing onto the
similar doc's path (the dedup-overwrite defect codified by the old tests).
#129: a custom rule scoped to a language the validator never reports (a
typo) is surfaced as a warn finding on .roboco/conventions.yml via the
runner's once-per-run validation; #32 (tsx->typescript dialect) stays
BY-DESIGN.
#130: _cache_put only swallows a UNIQUE violation (23505) as a concurrent
duplicate; a non-unique IntegrityError (FK/NOT NULL/check) is log-errored
and re-raised instead of being silently misattributed.
#132: health re-reads the live file status (a cached degraded row hid an
in-place repair at a stale head key); get_map skips cached degraded rows
and stops caching degraded so a repaired file re-derives. #134 BY-DESIGN.
#133: _DB_METHODS gains stream/stream_scalars (SQLAlchemy 2.0 streaming
constructs are data access too — a route calling them is not thin).
#199: regenerate_verb_tables._annot_str strips Annotated[...] metadata
(BeforeValidator) before rendering; regenerated verbs.md + per-role
prompts so the BeforeValidator(func=...) repr (with a memory address) no
longer leaks into agent-facing prompt text.
TDD: 206 conventions/docs tests green (incl. 5 new files / appended
cases); ruff + mypy clean.
* [chore] Cluster 16 — cross-cutting hygiene logical-gaps sweep
Disposition + fix the 10 cross-cutting-hygiene gaps, TDD. make quality green
(ruff, mypy 944 files, pytest, xenon, vulture, foundation-check, enum-parity).
FIX:
- #24 /ws/system now gated by _require_panel_token (matches every sibling
/ws/* stream); rejects a missing token in strict mode and a forged token
even in dev. (roboco/api/websocket.py)
- #25 two drifted _require_ceo implementations (orchestrator router vs release
handler) unified on a single require_ceo_role helper in deps — same 403,
same role set, accepts Role/AgentRole/"ceo". (roboco/api/deps.py,
routes/orchestrator.py, routes/release.py)
- #11 a spawn session for a delivery role (developer/qa/documenter) with no
task_id now logs an unattributed-usage warning via is_unattributed_delivery_spawn.
(roboco/runtime/orchestrator.py)
- #65 pricing returns a structured CostResult(cost_usd, unpriced, is_anthropic)
so an unpriced Anthropic model (real spend we'd undercount) is flagged
instead of silently $0; calculate_cost stays a thin float wrapper.
(roboco/billing/pricing.py, billing/__init__.py)
- #67 blocker-metrics "blocked since" reads the task.blocked audit transition
(indexed on target_id/event_type/timestamp), not updated_at — which
over-counted when a blocked task was touched for a non-blocking reason.
Falls back to updated_at/created_at only with no audit row.
(roboco/services/metrics.py)
- #94 grok refresh_if_stale uses double-checked locking (_refresh_lock +
_recheck_or_refresh) so two concurrent callers don't both POST the
single-use refresh grant and burn the credential. (grok_auth.py)
DOCS (fix the doc, behavior already correct/pinned by tests):
- #66 get_summary docstring corrected — it sums raw agent_spawn_sessions rows
(sub-day precise); daily_usage_rollups/get_today_summary can diverge for
"today" until the sweeper catches up. (roboco/services/usage.py)
- #68 DashboardStorage is a documented in-memory stub; added a test pinning
that auditor flags are lost on storage reset (persisting = a migration +
service refactor, out of scope as a half-implementation).
(tests/integration/test_dashboard_service.py)
BY-DESIGN (no code change, with file:line evidence):
- #28 dashboard reads are open to the authenticated operator (dashboard.py:36
documents this); mutating auditor routes already gate via
_require_auditor_or_ceo. Role-gating reads would break the panel (no
X-Agent-ID on dashboard reads) and CEO-token-gating the router would block
the Auditor (auditor token != CEO token). nginx is the prod boundary.
REFUTED (narrowing would reintroduce a documented hang):
- #93 the ~/.grok directory mount (vs a single auth.json file) is load-bearing
— a single-file bind mount pins the inode so the atomic tmp.replace refresh
doesn't propagate to running containers (they hang at grok's login prompt).
Already documented in grok.py:161 and locked by
test_intake_grok_mounts_subscription_auth_when_present.
Incidental gate-greening (mypy errors a stale .mypy_cache had hidden in
earlier-cluster test files; xenon refactors for the new B-threshold):
- tests/unit/test_regenerate_verb_tables.py: type the dynamic-module loader.
- tests/unit/services/test_prompter.py: annotate the draft dict as dict[str,Any].
- tests/unit/services/test_conventions_cache_put.py: _FakeOrig is a real Exception
(IntegrityError's orig arg requires BaseException).
- metrics._blocked_since_map extracted from get_blocker_metrics (complexity).
- intake_server._normalize_batch_drafts extracted from propose_batch (complexity).
* Docs update
* [bug] spawn: self-heal vanished clone + branch ref before worktree ensure (be-dev-1 fatal loop)
A vanished clone_root (disk loss / /data/workspaces wipe / manual cleanup)
fatal-looped the resume path: _ensure_worktree_before_spawn ran
`git -C <missing>` and released the claim, but the reaper-style release
preserves assigned_to + branch_name so the next dispatch is a RESUME
(create_branch never re-runs to re-clone) and the same missing clone failed
every ~30s.
- workspace.py: ensure_worktree_self_heal re-attaches a present worktree +
symlinks the shared .venv; on a missing local branch ref it fetches from
origin (create_branch pushes at claim time, so pushed work survives) and
re-creates the ref, falling back to -b origin/HEAD only when the branch
was never pushed. _fetch_branch_ref is the token-aware fetch helper.
- orchestrator.py: _ensure_worktree_before_spawn health-checks the clone
and re-clones via ensure_workspace BEFORE the worktree self-heal. Fatal
git-state (WorkspaceError) still releases the claim + aborts; transient
failures abort without releasing (a fresh claim wouldn't help and
re-cloning is destructive).
TDD: 21 new + 61 related worktree/git/cancel/cleanup tests green; ruff +
mypy clean.
---------
Co-authored-by: Renn F <rennf93@users.noreply.github.com>
* chore: clean make quality baseline on feature/lifecycle-canonical-spec
Three classes of pre-existing issues blocking `make quality`:
1. Alembic migrations 002/009/011 used runtime introspection
(op.get_bind() + inspect / bind.execute) without guarding for
offline (--sql) mode. `alembic upgrade head --sql` is part of
`make quality`; in offline mode `op.get_bind()` returns a
MockConnection with no inspection system, so the migrations
crashed before emitting their SQL stubs. Each migration now
short-circuits or simplifies in `context.is_offline_mode()` —
live-DB behavior is unchanged.
2. ruff format drift on three files left over from prior in-flight
edits (choreographer/_impl.py, content_actions.py, and one test
file). `ruff format` applied.
3. vulture flagged two unused `tb` parameters in async __aexit__
stubs in test_task_service_lifecycle_misc.py. The parameter is
protocol-required but unused by the body — renamed to `_tb`
(vulture treats underscore-prefixed names as intentionally unused).
`make quality` is now green from this branch's HEAD; subsequent
lifecycle-spec work can use it as the per-task gate.
* feat(lifecycle): canonical spec package + Role/Status/TaskType enums
Foundation for the canonical lifecycle/permissions module. Enums
mirror docs/internal/old/workflows/STATUS_TRANSITIONS.md +
PERMISSIONS.md. Tests pin enum membership against both the
predecessor canon and roboco.models.base.TaskType.
* feat(lifecycle): Decision dataclass with allow/reject/tracing_gap constructors
Single rejection shape every consumer maps to its native format
(Envelope, HTTP code, prompt hint). __post_init__ enforces the
allowed/rejection_kind invariants so a malformed Decision can't reach
a consumer.
* fix(lifecycle): tighten Decision invariants per Task 2 review
Two reviewer findings on the Task 2 Decision dataclass, addressed
in one commit:
1. The docstring promised `allowed=True ⇒ rejection_kind is None
AND missing == [] AND remediate is None`, but __post_init__ only
checked the rejection_kind half. A caller could construct an
allow-shaped Decision with stale missing/remediate fields and
sneak it past validation. Tighten __post_init__ to enforce the
full invariant. Add a regression test.
2. tracing_gap defensively copies the missing list (`list(missing)`)
to isolate the stored list from later caller-side mutation, but
no test pinned this. Add a regression test that mutates the source
list after construction and asserts the stored list is unchanged.
Issue 2 from the same review (mutable list vs tuple for `missing`)
is a broader design call deferred until consumers exist; the
defensive copy is sufficient until then.
* feat(lifecycle): Precondition/ActionSpec/IntentSpec/StatusTransition dataclasses
The four dataclasses that hold the canonical tables. ActionSpec and
StatusTransition are direct ports of pre-gateway PERMISSIONS.md +
STATUS_TRANSITIONS.md rows. IntentSpec is the gateway-only addition:
each gateway intent verb declares which atomic actions it composes.
* feat(lifecycle): _STATUS_TRANSITIONS table + STATUS_GRAPH view
Direct port of STATUS_TRANSITIONS.md. Every transition records its
trigger action and (optionally) a role constraint. STATUS_GRAPH is
the precomputed source→{targets} view callers use for reachability
checks.
* fix(lifecycle): pin role_constraint values + clarify Task-5 handoff
Two reviewer findings on Task 4 _STATUS_TRANSITIONS, addressed in
one commit:
1. The original Task-4 tests verified (source, target) pairs but
not role_constraint contents. A typo in a single role name (e.g.
forgetting MAIN_PM from escalate_to_ceo) would have slipped past
them silently. Add test_status_transitions_role_constraints_match_canon
pinning every non-None constraint and the cancel-block invariant.
2. role_constraint=None on the `claim` rows from PENDING and
NEEDS_REVISION was load-bearing — it is the explicit handoff
point between the StatusTransition table (state machine layer)
and CLAIM_RULES (per-role claim authority, lands in Task 5).
The original inline comment said this in passing; expand it so
the design choice is unmissable for a stranger reading just
spec.py.
* feat(lifecycle): _ATOMIC_ACTIONS + CLAIM_RULES + ROLE_TEAM_RULES tables
Direct port of PERMISSIONS.md. Every task management tool gets an
ActionSpec with allowed_roles, source_statuses, target_status,
self_review_block, and needs_team_match flags. CLAIM_RULES maps each
Role to the statuses they can claim from. ROLE_TEAM_RULES is the
per-slug team restriction.
* fix(lifecycle): tighten ActionSpec contracts per Task 5 review
Three reviewer findings on Task 5's _ATOMIC_ACTIONS table, addressed
in one commit:
1. set_plan.source_statuses widened to {CLAIMED, IN_PROGRESS} but
every existing caller (i_will_work_on / i_will_plan compositions)
runs set_plan while CLAIMED, between claim and start. Narrow to
{CLAIMED} only. If a future "edit plan mid-flight" feature lands,
widen explicitly with test coverage at that time.
2. needs_team_match was set True only on claim/qa_pass/qa_fail/
docs_complete. Defense-in-depth says every role-scoped task
action should re-assert team match (don't rely on the inheritance
chain through assigned_to alone). Flip to True on: start,
set_plan, block, pause, submit_verification, submit_qa,
submit_pm_review, complete, create_subtask. Leave False on
board/CEO actions and PM cross-cell interventions (unblock,
resume, cancel) where the cross-cell semantics are intentional.
3. claim.source_statuses is intentionally a SUPERSET of any single
role's CLAIM_RULES allowance (the table holds the union; CLAIM_RULES
holds the per-role authority). Add an inline comment above the
claim ActionSpec so a future reader doesn't conclude the two
tables disagree — they don't, they encode overlapping facts at
different grains.
* feat(lifecycle): _INTENT_VERBS table — every gateway verb declared
Each gateway intent verb is now a named composition of atomic actions
plus optional side effects. i_will_work_on = (claim, set_plan, start);
i_am_done = (submit_verification, submit_qa); open_pr is pure side
effects (push_branch, create_pr); etc.
* fix(lifecycle): widen block.allowed_roles to include QA + Documenter
Task 6 review caught a role-set inconsistency: i_am_blocked.allowed_roles
admits dev/QA/doc, but the underlying block.allowed_roles only allowed
dev+PM. Result: a QA or documenter calling i_am_blocked would pass the
IntentSpec gate and then be rejected by the composed ActionSpec gate
when Task 7 wires can_invoke_intent.
Widen block to include QA + Documenter. The semantic case is sound: a
QA reviewing a task can discover an external blocker; a documenter
writing docs may need PM intervention. Predecessor PERMISSIONS.md
restricted block to dev+PM, but with the gateway exposing i_am_blocked
to all worker roles, the underlying atomic must agree.
The deeper unclaim/escalate_up "imperative verb" concern from the same
review (composes=() but mutates state) is deferred to Task 8 where the
validator design lands.
* feat(lifecycle): public lookup functions + Context + preconditions
can_claim, can_invoke_action, can_invoke_intent, valid_next_verbs,
composed_actions_for, intents_for_role, status_after — the entire
public surface every consumer will use. Context carries the
caller-supplied state preconditions need (plan, journal-decision
flag, etc.). Preconditions for plan/commits/no_pr/ownership are
declared once and wired into the relevant IntentSpecs.
* fix(lifecycle): wire PRECONDITION_OWNERSHIP through Context.actor_id
Task 7 review found _p_owns_task reads agent.id but every call site
passes None for the agent arg. Result: getattr(None, "id", object())
returns a fresh sentinel, task.assigned_to == <sentinel> is always
False, and open_pr / i_am_done would reject every owner the moment
Task 9 wires consumers.
Fix: thread identity through Context.actor_id (new UUID field) and
rewrite _p_owns_task to read from the context. Both call sites already
pass the Context — no signature changes elsewhere. Add green-path
test exercising the owner-can-open-pr case the existing tests
missed (the Task 7 plan only tested precondition-failure paths,
which masked the bug).
Plus surface hygiene: STATUS_GRAPH, CLAIM_RULES, ROLE_TEAM_RULES,
and the four PRECONDITION_* constants are now in
roboco.lifecycle.__init__.__all__ so consumers in Tasks 8/9 don't
depend on the implicit `from roboco.lifecycle.spec import ...`
backdoor.
* feat(lifecycle): import-time self-consistency validators
10 validators run at module import; first failure raises
LifecycleSpecError and prevents the package from loading. Covers
status enum coverage, reachability, terminal exits, intent
compositions, status chain consistency, claim-rule role/status
coverage, self-review symmetry, team-rule slug existence, and
StatusTransition action references.
* fix(lifecycle): close validator gaps; resolve BACKLOG-claim and submit_qa IN_PROGRESS-shortcut ambiguity
Three reviewer follow-ups on Task 8's _validate.py, plus two real
data corrections the new action-target-reachability validator
surfaced.
1. Design spec §9 calls for "every ActionSpec.target_status, when
set, is reachable from each source_status via STATUS_GRAPH" —
missing from Task 8's 10 validators. Add
_check_action_target_reachable_from_source.
2. _check_role_team_rules_slugs verified slug existence in
AGENT_UUIDS but NOT that the cell team in ROLE_TEAM_RULES
matches the seed. Add _check_role_team_rules_team_match,
scoped to non-None entries only — None means "exempt from
team-match enforcement" (cross-cell roles), not "no team in
org chart".
3. test_validators_pass_on_real_spec was ceremonial. Add
test_run_all_validators_raises_on_unknown_intent_action,
a deliberate-break regression that monkeypatches _INTENT_VERBS
to inject a fake action and asserts LifecycleSpecError raises.
The new action-target-reachability validator caught two real
data inconsistencies between the predecessor canon docs and the
spec tables:
A. claim.source_statuses listed BACKLOG and CLAIM_RULES[*PM]
listed BACKLOG, but STATUS_GRAPH[BACKLOG] = {PENDING, CANCELLED}
only. Resolution: PMs use the explicit \`activate\` action to
move BACKLOG → PENDING, then claim from PENDING. Drop BACKLOG
from claim.source_statuses and CLAIM_RULES.
B. submit_qa.source_statuses listed IN_PROGRESS, but
STATUS_GRAPH[IN_PROGRESS] does NOT include AWAITING_QA. The
intent verb i_am_done composes (submit_verification, submit_qa)
which forces IN_PROGRESS → VERIFYING → AWAITING_QA — no
shortcut. Drop the stale IN_PROGRESS entry from
submit_qa.source_statuses.
Both corrections tighten the canonical state machine to a strict
no-skip transition graph. Pre-gateway PERMISSIONS.md/STATUS_TRANSITIONS.md
disagreements are resolved here; spec.py is the canon now.
* feat(gateway): Envelope.from_decision maps lifecycle Decisions to envelopes
Single shape adapter so verb bodies stop hand-composing rejection
envelopes. Each rejection_kind maps to a specific envelope flavor;
'self_review' folds into 'not_authorized' with a parenthetical hint;
constructing from an allow Decision raises (programmer error).
* feat(gateway): VerbRunner for atomic composed-action dispatch
Wraps spec.composed_actions_for(intent) in session.begin_nested()
so mid-sequence failures roll the DB back. Side effects run AFTER
the savepoint commits. Each atomic action name dispatches to a
TaskService method via a single, exhaustive _dispatch_atomic
mapping. New verbs slot in by adding an IntentSpec entry + a
_dispatch_atomic case if a new atomic is needed.
* refactor(gateway): i_will_work_on uses spec.can_invoke_intent + VerbRunner
Replace the bespoke status-branch dispatcher in i_will_work_on with the
spec-driven flow: load task -> load agent -> build spec.Context ->
spec.can_invoke_intent (and spec.can_claim for per-role status authority)
-> Envelope.from_decision on rejection -> VerbRunner.run_intent on success.
The _i_will_work_on_pending, _i_will_work_on_claimed,
_i_will_work_on_needs_revision, and _start_failed_envelope helpers are
removed; the runner replaces them. Two narrow verb-body re-entry blocks
remain for behaviors the spec does not yet model:
1. in_progress + same agent -> idempotent heartbeat-only return
2. claimed + same agent -> _resume_from_claimed (set_plan + start)
to recover from a stuck mid-claim crash without re-running claim
against a state the spec excludes.
The behavioral claim guards (already_active / paused / sibling_sequence)
also stay imperative for now -- they're not in the spec yet and migrate
into spec.extra_preconditions in a later task. Per-role claim authority
is enforced via spec.can_claim because the atomic claim action's
source_statuses are the union across roles; CLAIM_RULES narrows.
Parity test in tests/lifecycle/test_consumer_parity.py runs the verb
against every (role x status x task_type='code') combo (112 rows) and
asserts the envelope error matches the spec's Decision (or can_claim's
Decision when the intent gate passes but per-role claim authority does
not). This is the contract that makes spec/verb drift impossible.
Existing tests updated where rejection-message text changed (the spec
now produces the messages, e.g. "role 'cell_pm' may not call
'i_will_work_on'" instead of "PM cannot execute code") or where the
spec's stricter view ("invalid_state" -> "not_authorized" for a dev
trying to claim awaiting_qa) is more accurate. Test fixtures were
updated to wire task.session.begin_nested as a proper async context
manager (required by VerbRunner) and to set agent_for().id so runner-
driven calls line up with assert_awaited_with(task_id, agent_id).
* refactor(lifecycle): push CLAIM_RULES enforcement into can_invoke_action
Task 11's i_will_work_on migration had to call spec.can_claim()
separately after spec.can_invoke_intent() because the claim action's
source_statuses is the union across all claim-eligible roles —
can_invoke_intent alone would let a developer pass for claiming
awaiting_qa (a QA-only state).
The retrofit pattern would repeat in every claim-composing verb
(i_will_plan, claim_review, claim_doc_task). Push the per-role
narrowing inside can_invoke_action when the action is "claim",
using the same not_authorized vs invalid_state disambiguation
can_claim already implemented (status-reserved-for-another-role
returns not_authorized; status-no-role-can-claim returns
invalid_state). Extracted the body to _check_claim_rules_narrow
to keep can_invoke_action under xenon's complexity threshold.
Update _i_will_work_on_gate to drop the redundant spec.can_claim
call. Update test_consumer_parity.py to assert only against
can_invoke_intent's Decision.
Tasks 12-22 will inherit the cleaner pattern: spec.can_invoke_intent
is the single gate; verb bodies don't need per-action retrofits.
* refactor(gateway): i_will_plan uses spec.can_invoke_intent + VerbRunner
Migrates i_will_plan to the spec-driven pattern Task 11 set up for
i_will_work_on. The verb body now: (1) loads task + agent, (2) builds
Context, (3) checks idempotent/recovery re-entry, (4) calls
spec.can_invoke_intent, (5) returns Envelope.from_decision on
rejection, (6) delegates composition to VerbRunner. The
_i_will_plan_* helpers are removed — the runner replaces them.
Parity test in tests/lifecycle/test_consumer_parity.py runs the verb
against every (role × status × task_type) combo and asserts the
envelope matches spec.Decision.
* refactor(gateway): delegate uses spec.can_invoke_intent for role/state gate
Migrates delegate to the spec-driven role/state gate. The chain
validation (main_pm->cell_pm, cell_pm->its team's devs), the
assignee-vs-task_type rule (Cell PMs receive planning-typed only),
the enum coercion, and the parent-lifecycle/cap guards STAY in the
verb body — they encode delegate-specific semantics the spec
doesn't model.
Parity test in tests/lifecycle/test_consumer_parity.py asserts the
spec's role+state rejection is correctly surfaced. Chain/assignee
rejections continue to be tested in test_choreographer_pm_extras.
* refactor(gateway): open_pr uses spec.can_invoke_intent + VerbRunner
Migrates open_pr to spec-driven gating. The spec's
extra_preconditions (PRECONDITION_OWNERSHIP, PRECONDITION_COMMITS,
PRECONDITION_NO_PR) handle all three precondition checks; the verb
body delegates side-effect dispatch (push_branch, create_pr) to
VerbRunner.
Idempotent re-entry retained: an open_pr call against a task that
already has a PR (and the caller owns it) returns OK without
re-opening, rather than the tracing_gap the spec would otherwise
produce. This preserves agent ergonomics — two calls in a row
shouldn't surface a misleading "no_prior_pr" hint.
Parity test in tests/lifecycle/test_consumer_parity.py runs the verb
against representative (status x commits x pr_number) combos and
asserts the envelope matches spec.Decision.
* refactor(gateway): i_am_done uses spec.can_invoke_intent + VerbRunner
Migrates i_am_done to spec-driven gating. The spec's
extra_preconditions (PRECONDITION_OWNERSHIP, PRECONDITION_COMMITS)
handle ownership and commit-count checks; VerbRunner dispatches
the (submit_verification, submit_qa) atomic chain.
The tracing-gate preconditions (progress entry, journal:reflect,
acceptance criteria) and the field-level submit-qa gates stay in
the verb body — they model gates the spec doesn't yet cover.
Defense-in-depth: those gates run after the spec accepts the
ownership/commits checks.
Parity test in tests/lifecycle/test_consumer_parity.py runs the
verb against (role × status × ownership × commits) and asserts
the envelope matches spec.Decision.
* refactor(gateway): i_am_blocked uses spec.can_invoke_intent + VerbRunner
Migrates i_am_blocked to spec-driven gating. The journal:struggle
write stays in the verb body (it's a side effect outside the
lifecycle action). VerbRunner dispatches the `block` atomic action
via task_service.escalate.
Parity test in tests/lifecycle/test_consumer_parity.py.
* refactor(gateway): unclaim and resume use spec.can_invoke_intent
Migrates both verbs to the spec-driven gate. unclaim's verb body
keeps its dispatch (task.unclaim_for_agent) because composes=();
resume goes through VerbRunner with composes=("resume",).
The reassignment-rejection branch (introduced in 19f27b4 for the
2026-05-08 trace's "not your claim" case) stays - the spec doesn't
model "task got reassigned out from under you by an upstream verb,"
and the existing envelope text ("current owner: X - call
give_me_work() to find your current work") is the load-bearing
hint that fixed the original bug. Extracted the shared branch into
_reassigned_rejection / _ReassignedCtx so both verbs reuse it
without duplicating the envelope construction.
Parity tests in tests/lifecycle/test_consumer_parity.py.
* refactor(gateway): complete uses spec.can_invoke_intent at the dispatcher
Migrates the top-level `complete` dispatcher to gate role/state via
spec.can_invoke_intent before routing to cell_pm_complete or
main_pm_complete. The two lower-level methods keep their existing
PR-merge / CEO-escalation logic and pre-flight guards (those model
journal:decision preconditions and PR-mergeability checks the spec
doesn't model yet).
The runner pattern is NOT applied here — `complete` has two divergent
runtime paths (Cell PM merges leaf into parent branch; Main PM opens
master PR + escalates to CEO) that don't fit the runner's
single-composition model. Verb-body-owns-dispatch is the right
pattern.
Parity test in tests/lifecycle/test_consumer_parity.py runs the
verb against (role × status) combos and asserts the dispatcher's
spec rejection is correctly surfaced.
* refactor(gateway): escalate_up, escalate_to_ceo, submit_up use spec.can_invoke_intent
Migrates the three PM-side escalation/submission verbs to
spec-driven role/state gating. The verb-specific guards
(journal:decision, escalation_target configured, _submit_up_guard's
ownership + notes-length + subtasks-terminal) STAY in the verb body
- the spec doesn't model these.
escalate_up has composes=() so the verb body owns dispatch via
task.escalate. escalate_to_ceo and submit_up route their
compositions through VerbRunner.
Parity tests in tests/lifecycle/test_consumer_parity.py.
* refactor(gateway): qa.py + doc.py role mixins use spec.can_invoke_intent
Migrates the five QA + Documenter verbs (claim_review, pass_review,
fail_review, claim_doc_task, i_documented) to spec-driven gating.
The self-review block lives at the atomic-action layer
(_ATOMIC_ACTIONS["qa_pass"|"qa_fail"|"docs_complete"].self_review_block=True)
and naturally fires when the verb body builds a Context with
actor_slug==original_developer_slug. No verb-body retrofits needed.
The verb-specific helpers (_verify_qa_owner, _qa_pass_gate_check,
_check_i_documented_inputs) STAY — they encode notes-length /
journal:learning / files-list / qa_evidence_inspected gates the
spec doesn't model.
claim_review and claim_doc_task own dispatch via task.qa_claim /
task.doc_claim respectively (not the runner) because those
specialized claim methods keep status at AWAITING_QA /
AWAITING_DOCUMENTATION, which is what the downstream qa_pass /
qa_fail / docs_complete source-status requirement expects.
The spec gate still validates role + claim source-status + task_type
before dispatch.
pass_review / fail_review / i_documented route their compositions
(qa_pass / qa_fail / docs_complete) through VerbRunner.run_intent
inside a savepoint.
Parity tests in tests/lifecycle/test_consumer_parity.py for all
five verbs.
* fix(lifecycle): claim_review and claim_doc_task have empty composes
Tasks 21-22 surfaced a real spec/runtime mismatch: both verbs were
declared composes=("claim", "start"), but the actual implementation
uses task.qa_claim / task.doc_claim which intentionally keep status
at AWAITING_QA / AWAITING_DOCUMENTATION. If the runner ever ran the
declared composition, it would transition the task to CLAIMED then
IN_PROGRESS, breaking the source-status invariants of qa_pass,
qa_fail, and docs_complete.
The spec is the canon — align it to the runtime. composes=() means
"verb body owns dispatch" (same pattern as escalate_up and unclaim).
The spec gate still validates role + AWAITING_QA / AWAITING_
DOCUMENTATION source-status via the role's CLAIM_RULES narrowing,
enforced through special handling in can_invoke_intent, so role/state
safety is preserved.
* refactor(gateway): role_config flow lists derived from spec.intents_for_role
Hand-maintained _DEV_FLOW etc. tuples replaced with calls into the
spec. Adding/removing a role from an IntentSpec.allowed_roles now
automatically updates the MCP manifest. The spec is the canon;
role_config becomes a thin shim that adds the do-tool / write /
subagent / description metadata the spec doesn't carry.
* feat(lifecycle): generators + make lifecycle for deterministic artifact regen
Renders intent-verbs.md, status-transitions.md, panel/lib/lifecycle.json,
and per-role agents/prompts/_generated/lifecycle-{role}.md fragments
from the canonical spec. `make lifecycle` runs the regenerator;
deterministic output enables CI to gate on `git diff --exit-code` after
running it. The agent prompt fragments will be injected at the top of
each role's system prompt (Task 25) so agents see the same verbs the
gateway accepts.
* feat(lifecycle): inject generated prompt fragments + CI drift gate
Each agent's system prompt now starts with the spec-generated
'verbs available to your role' fragment. CI runs make lifecycle
and fails if regeneration produces a diff — drift between spec
and artifacts cannot land on master.
* refactor(gateway): delete verb_gates.py — superseded by lifecycle.spec
verb_gates.is_verb_allowed and verb_gates.valid_next_verbs are now
spec.can_invoke_intent(...).allowed and spec.valid_next_verbs.
Importers updated to consume the canonical spec module directly.
tests/unit/gateway/test_verb_gates.py removed — coverage lives in
tests/lifecycle/test_spec.py.
envelope.with_introspection wraps spec.valid_next_verbs with role-string
coercion + best-effort try/except so malformed task fixtures (AsyncMock
status) and unknown role strings still yield [] instead of raising —
preserves the legacy verb_gates contract.
content_actions content-tool RBAC (commit/notify) is now a pair of
explicit role frozensets in this file. These are content tools, not
lifecycle intents, so they intentionally do NOT live in spec._INTENT_VERBS.
Two existing introspection tests asserted "commit" in valid_next_verbs;
fixed to assert open_pr/i_am_done — commit is correctly absent under
the canonical spec because it is a do-server content tool, not a flow
intent verb.
* refactor(gateway): collapse scattered role constants into spec
The pm_cannot_execute_code_guard and role_typed_claim_guard guards
both modeled rules the spec now handles via can_invoke_action's
CLAIM_RULES narrowing and ActionSpec.allowed_task_types. Drop them
from claim_guards.py — the choreographer's existing skip-flags on
_run_claim_guards are now permanent: those guards no longer fire.
Simplify _run_claim_guards's signature accordingly.
The concurrency-invariant guards (already_active_guard,
paused_tasks_guard, sibling_sequence_guard) STAY — the spec doesn't
model these system-level invariants. sibling_sequence_guard's loop
body extracted into _earlier_blocking_sibling helper to keep the
slimmed module under xenon's --max-modules A average.
* refactor(enforcement): task_lifecycle becomes a thin view of lifecycle.spec
VALID_TRANSITIONS and ROLE_RESTRICTED_TRANSITIONS are now derived
from roboco.lifecycle.spec — no independent tables. The 433-line
file collapses to ~30 lines of view definitions; future changes
go in spec.py. Helper functions exported by the legacy module are
preserved as thin wrappers so existing consumers don't need to
change their imports today.
A small _LEGACY_OPERATIONAL_EDGES table sits alongside the
spec-derived view to cover transitions the runtime exercises but
the spec has not yet absorbed (voluntary unclaim, reaper sweep,
PM-direct completes from in_progress, parallel-doc-PR developer
trigger). It is fenced and clearly documented; once those callers
are migrated to spec-driven dispatch the constant goes empty and
the file collapses to a pure view.
A test in test_task_service_lifecycle_misc.py was rewritten: the
predecessor asserted CEO-only authority over awaiting_ceo_approval
cancels (legacy table behavior), but the canonical spec authorizes
{CELL_PM, MAIN_PM, CEO} uniformly across all non-terminal cancel
sources. The test now exercises the broader spec-defined cascade.
* feat(lifecycle): UNMIGRATED guard pins known-debt consumers
Two pieces of debt surfaced during Task 28's collapse of
enforcement/task_lifecycle.py: (1) ~11 operational edges still in
the shim's _LEGACY_OPERATIONAL_EDGES because the spec's
_STATUS_TRANSITIONS doesn't yet model them; (2) role-gate
disagreements in _LEGACY_ROLE_GATES that the spec disagrees with.
UNMIGRATED is the named-debt set; KNOWN_UNMIGRATED_CONSUMERS pins
the catalog so a contributor adding a new entry must update both
sides. Validator (_check_unmigrated_is_subset) fires at import if
they drift. Test pins the current entries.
Phase 3's terminal invariant is `UNMIGRATED == frozenset()` —
expected when both legacy data carriers fold into spec, at which
point the assertion becomes a permanent regression guard.
* test(lifecycle): tier 3 end-to-end real-DB happy paths
Eight integration tests covering every major lifecycle path:
dev (pending → awaiting_qa), QA pass, QA fail, doc handoff,
Cell PM complete, Main PM escalate-to-CEO, block+unblock,
pause+resume. Each test drives the spec → choreographer →
TaskService → DB stack with only the git layer mocked. Catches
"spec says X, DB constraint says Y" mismatches the unit-tier
parametrized parity suite cannot detect.
* test(lifecycle): tier 4 smoke replay — pin known-bug shapes after spec migration
Synthesized fixture covering the 9 bugs from the 2026-05-08
audit-log trace + the 2 from the 2026-05-09 follow-up trace. Each
record documents (verb, role, task setup, expected post-fix
envelope shape, fix commit, spec invariant). The replay test
parametrizes over the records and asserts the spec / choreographer
behavior now matches the post-fix expectation — locks in the
fixes as permanent regressions.
The original audit log was wiped during cleanup; the fixture is
a documented synthesis, not a verbatim capture. The bug list is
faithful to the prior session's analysis of the trace.
* fix(orchestrator): silence dev-dispatcher noise for non-dev-lane tasks
Dev dispatcher fetched all pending/claimed/in_progress tasks regardless
of assignee role and warned 'role/task_type mismatch' on each pass when
it found cell_pm/main_pm/product_owner/etc. tasks — those belong to
_dispatch_pm_work, not this lane. The 30s warning loop showed up
prominently in the 2026-05-10 smoke run.
Filter at the lane boundary: silently skip when assignee role is not
developer/documenter/unknown. The D-49 misassignment warning still
fires for the legitimate cases (developer assigned a documentation
task, etc.).
* fix(gateway,prompts): unblock the three smoke-run dead-ends
Three issues surfaced by the 2026-05-10 smoke run, fixed together
because they're all blockers for end-to-end task completion:
1. Acceptance-criteria tracing gate was unsatisfiable. Nothing in the
codebase writes to task.acceptance_criteria_status, so
_check_acceptance_criteria always returned every criterion as
missing. Treat a reflect note as the addressing artifact: when the
agent has written one, the gate clears. Per-criterion citation via
acceptance_criteria_status is still honored when populated, so the
schema stays available for future per-criterion tracking.
2. Cell PM runaway re-decomposition. On every wake-up be-pm
re-decomposed its parent task without checking for existing
children, producing duplicate dev subtasks. cell_pm.md now teaches
'list children before delegating' and 'one dev subtask is usually
enough — QA/Documenter/PM-merge engage automatically'. Added
anti-pattern entries for re-decomposition and over-decomposition.
3. Main PM exit/respawn loop on claimed-state tasks. The model
cycled through delegate/resume/escalate/unblock looking for a verb
that worked on 'claimed', and got cleanly rejected by every one.
The right verb is i_will_plan (it composes claim+set_plan+start
and resumes from claimed). main_pm.md now spells this out
explicitly with a worked example of which verbs reject and why.
* feat(prompts): restore pre-gateway lifecycle scaffolding across all 6 roles
The gateway migration shrank role prompts from ~50 lines to ~15
(commit 534152c for dev; analogous shrinks for qa/doc/cell_pm/main_pm/board
in e12a596, 05ac832, 8dc381b). The verb surface got cleaner but the
prescription for using verbs through the lifecycle disappeared. The
2026-05-10 smoke run surfaced the regression: agents thrash through
verbs hoping one fits, journal sparsely, skip the dev reflect note,
and (for cell PMs) re-decompose on every wake-up.
Each role prompt now restores three sections that the pre-gateway
versions had:
1. State -> Verb table — what to call when respawned in each
lifecycle status. Eliminates the verb-cycling antipattern: the
agent looks up its current status and calls the one verb that
transitions out of it.
2. Mandatory pre-handoff checklist — explicit walk-through of the
gates the next verb will check, ordered so the agent fixes the
missing piece before retrying:
- developer: 7 items before i_am_done
- qa: 8 items before pass/fail (incl. self-review forbidden,
read dev journal not just diff, name artifact per criterion)
- doc: 7 items before i_documented
- cell_pm: 7 items before submit_up (incl. integration green)
- main_pm: 7 items before complete(root)
- board: separate checklists for escalate_to_ceo (PO/HoM) and
reflect-note quality (Auditor — its only output)
3. Journaling cadence — when to use each of the five scopes
(note/decision/struggle/learning/reflect). The pre-gateway
prompts named all five scopes with role-specific examples;
the post-gateway prompts mention 'reflect' once and skip the
rest. Restored across every role.
Plus restored the load-bearing rules that got dropped:
- Cell PM: 'A SINGLE subtask flows through dev -> QA -> doc ->
PM-merge. DON'T split into per-role subtasks.' This is exactly
what be-pm violated in the smoke run, creating duplicate
'branch naming subtask' / 'PR workflow subtask' / etc.
- QA + Doc: 'read the dev's journal, not just the diff' — pre-
gateway forced this via roboco_journal_read_team; post-gateway
the inline data exists but the agent isn't told to use it.
- Developer: 'every acceptance criterion gets a citation in the
reflect note' — pairs with the tracing-gate change in 75b667d
where the reflect note is treated as the addressing artifact.
* feat(foundation): bootstrap foundation/identity.py with Role/Team/RoleLevel
Phase 1 task 1 of the foundation canonicalization plan
(docs/superpowers/specs/2026-05-10-foundation-canonicalization-design.md).
Three enums, no consumers yet — separate tasks migrate the existing
forks (models.base.AgentRole, lifecycle.spec.Role, agents_config role
sets, services/permissions.PM_ROLES) onto this canonical surface.
* feat(foundation/identity): add AGENTS catalog (single source for slug->role+team+UUID)
Resolves head-marketing.team drift (spec §5.1) by setting Team.BOARD
authoritatively. Team.MARKETING remains in the enum for legacy seed
data but no agent claims it; flagged for removal in cleanup.
* feat(foundation/identity): add role-sets + ROLE_LEVEL hierarchy
* feat(foundation/identity): add lookups + public API re-exports
* feat(foundation): import-time validators (uniqueness, role coverage, role-level)
* chore(foundation): verify+align postgres agentrole/team enums with foundation/identity
scripts/verify_postgres_enums.py reads the live agentrole+team enums
from postgres (via asyncpg using roboco.config.settings.database_*)
and compares them against the foundation Role+Team enums. Exits 0 on
match, 1 on drift (with a per-side diff), and 1 with a clear message
if postgres is unreachable so callers like make foundation-check can
treat that as a skip.
alembic/versions/012_align_agentrole_team_with_foundation.py is the
forward-only safety-net migration. It runs ALTER TYPE agentrole ADD
VALUE IF NOT EXISTS 'system' (idempotent on postgres >= 9.6) so any
DB without the recently-added Role.SYSTEM sentinel gets it on next
upgrade. Postgres has no DROP VALUE primitive without a destructive
type recreation, so foundation keeps legacy values (e.g. Team.MARKETING)
to absorb the inverse direction; the migration's downgrade is
intentionally a no-op.
Local verification deferred: postgres is not reachable from this
workstation (role 'roboco' does not exist), so the script could not
confirm the live enum shape. The migration is idempotent and runs
unconditionally on the next alembic upgrade head, and whoever next
runs make foundation-check against a live DB will get the post-migration
proof of alignment.
* refactor(lifecycle): re-export Role from foundation.identity (single source)
* refactor(models): re-export AgentRole and Team from foundation.identity
Removes the parallel Team and AgentRole StrEnum definitions in
models/base.py. They are now bound to roboco.foundation.identity.Role
and roboco.foundation.identity.Team respectively, so AgentRole IS
identity.Role (same Python class object). SQLAlchemy column types
bound as sa.Enum(AgentRole, name='agentrole') continue to work because
identity is preserved across import paths.
Note: foundation.Team drops the legacy 'fullstack' member that lived
on models.base.Team. The two _resolve_team_dir tests that used
Team.FULLSTACK to exercise the 'fullstack' branch now pass the literal
string 'fullstack' instead — same code path, no enum-membership coupling.
Adds two identity assertions to tests/foundation/test_role_reexport.py
verifying AgentRole is identity.Role and Team is identity.Team.
* fix(foundation): correct Team enum — add FULLSTACK, remove QA
The original plan's audit incorrectly identified the models/base.Team
membership. Actual original was 7 values: backend, frontend, ux_ui,
fullstack, main_pm, board, marketing. My plan replaced fullstack with
qa and added system — but qa was never a team (only a role).
Postgres team enum has fullstack (alembic 009), and services/task.py:675
+ services/git.py:779 branch on the literal "fullstack". Without
foundation.Team.FULLSTACK, any Project row with assigned_cell="fullstack"
would fail to round-trip through the SQLAlchemy ORM.
This correction:
- Adds FULLSTACK; removes QA from foundation.Team
- Updates the 8-value test expected set
- Restores tests/integration/test_task_service_misc.py to use Team.FULLSTACK
* refactor(agents_config): derive AGENT_ROLE_MAP/AGENT_TEAM_MAP/CELL_MEMBERS from foundation
* refactor(roles): canonicalize role-sets via foundation.identity
- agents_config.PM_ROLES (5-role: PMs + board + CEO) renamed to
TASK_CREATOR_ROLES; the name PM_ROLES is reserved for the canonical
2-role set (CELL_PM + MAIN_PM) defined in foundation.identity.
- agents_config._BOARD_ROLES aliased to foundation.BOARD_ROLES (drops
main_pm from the set; board A2A handler updated to keep allowing
board -> main_pm direct messaging via explicit branch).
- services/permissions.PM_ROLES (2-role) re-exported from foundation.
Closes the silent semantic divergence flagged in spec section 3 (HIGH severity).
* refactor(seeds,orchestrator): derive agent catalogs from foundation
- seeds/initial_data.AGENT_UUIDS derived from foundation.AGENTS.
- DEFAULT_AGENTS row generation pulls slug+role+team+id from foundation;
per-agent presentation strings (display name) stay in this file in
_AGENT_PRESENTATION dict. The system sentinel remains a literal with
team=None because the postgres `team` enum has no 'system' value.
- runtime/orchestrator._AGENT_TEAM_MAP and the cell-prefix table replaced
with foundation.team_for_slug. _AGENT_TEAM_MAP is now a derived ClassVar
covering every slug (not just management).
- head-marketing.team resolved to "board" (was "marketing" in seed +
orchestrator, "board" in agents_config — three-way drift, now unified).
- ceo.team resolved to "board" (was None in seed; foundation declares
board membership so the seed-bootstrapped DB row now reflects that).
- Adds tests/foundation/test_seed_orchestrator_parity.py — gate against
future drift between seed/orchestrator and foundation.
Closes the identity sub-phase. Adding an agent edits exactly one file:
foundation/identity.py:AGENTS.
* feat(foundation/policy): task_completeness rules + denylist
Implements spec §5.2: field-level completeness rules at create/delegate
time, plus the denylist that catches the literal placeholder string from
the deleted services/task.py:5061-5062 silent fallback ("completed and
reviewed by assignee" — agents copy-paste this from old logs).
CompletenessSpec is data; check() is a pure function; field_hints map
gives the agent the literal answer key for each missing field.
* feat(envelope): add incomplete_input envelope kind for interrogation pattern
Sister to tracing_gap; distinct error code lets agent prompts teach
incomplete_input handling separately from tracing-gap recovery. Carries
missing + field_hints + remediate for the spec §5.2.1 interrogation
pattern; Task 19 will wire the gateway delegate verb to use it.
* feat(foundation/task_completeness): auto-fill helpers (team, priority, parent)
* feat(api/schemas): DelegateRequest enforces TASK_AT_CREATE constraints
Removes silent defaults for nature/task_type/estimated_complexity;
adds min_length=20 to description; requires non-empty acceptance_criteria.
Mirrors foundation.policy.task_completeness.TASK_AT_CREATE so under-filled
delegate calls fail at the request boundary (422) instead of being silently
papered over downstream.
Tests touching delegate calls updated to pass the now-required fields.
* feat(models/task): TaskCreate + TaskCreateRequest enforce TASK_AT_CREATE
* feat(api/schemas): TaskUpdate rejects blanking acceptance_criteria
Golden Rule preservation — acceptance_criteria cannot be set to []/None
via PATCH. Pydantic field min_length doesn't catch explicit None, so a
model_validator(mode='before') guards the patch payload.
* fix(services/task): delete silent acceptance_criteria fallback (skeleton-task root cause)
The fallback at services/task.py:5061-5062 silently replaced empty
acceptance_criteria with ['completed and reviewed by assignee'] -
the proximate cause of every skeleton task in the 2026-05-10 smoke
run. Removed; create_subtask now invokes foundation.policy.task_completeness
and raises TaskCompletenessError on missing fields (spec section 5.2).
Two existing transition tests relied on a 1-char description default
that the new completeness check rejects (description min_length=20);
both updated to pass an explicit valid description. New integration
test pins the rejection contract (empty list + legacy phrase both
raise).
Companion code path at services/gateway/choreographer/_impl.py:1852
(the upstream `or []` collapse) is fixed in the next task.
* fix(gateway/delegate): use task_completeness + Envelope.incomplete_input
Replaces the `acceptance_criteria=inputs.acceptance_criteria or []`
collapse at _impl.py:1852 with a foundation.policy.task_completeness
check that rejects empty / placeholder input via
Envelope.incomplete_input — the spec section 5.2.1 interrogation pattern.
Auto-fill helpers (fill_team_from_assignee + fill_priority_from_parent)
fill the unambiguous fields before the check, then anything still
missing surfaces as a structured rejection with field_hints; the agent
gets a literal answer key for what to provide on retry.
DelegateInputs gains an explicit `nature` field (no default) so the
HTTP boundary can thread DelegateRequest.nature through to the
choreographer. Route handlers (flow_cell_pm, flow_main_pm) forward it.
The hardcoded TaskNature.TECHNICAL fallback in _create_subtask_from_inputs
is removed; the helper now coerces inputs.nature to the enum or raises
TaskCompletenessError if a non-gateway caller bypassed the check.
Closes the gateway-side path to skeleton tasks. Service-layer raise
(Task 18) remains as defense-in-depth for non-gateway callers.
Existing delegate-guard tests updated to pass full payloads — the
prior `title='x', description='y'` minimal stubs now hit the
completeness gate first; the full payloads still exercise the
auth/chain/cap guards downstream.
* feat(api/routes/tasks): POST /tasks uses foundation.task_completeness check
Replace the hand-rolled acceptance_criteria non-empty check in the
POST /tasks handler with a call to task_completeness.check(TASK_AT_CREATE,
data). Route, schema (TaskCreate), and service (TaskCreateRequest) now
all share one canonical notion of 'complete' — the fourth and final
create path is now strict.
Pydantic still rejects structurally invalid payloads (empty AC list,
short title/description, missing enums) with 422. The TC check at the
route boundary additionally rejects denylisted placeholder phrases
('completed and reviewed by assignee', etc.) that pass schema validation
but signal a stub task.
Add tests/integration/test_post_tasks_completeness.py:
- empty acceptance_criteria -> 422 (Pydantic)
- placeholder phrase -> 400/422 with 'acceptance_criteria' in body
* chore(make): add foundation-check drift gate (mirrors lifecycle-check)
* test(foundation): Phase 1 smoke gate — skeleton-task path returns incomplete_input
Phase 1 closes here: identity catalogs are single-sourced; the silent
acceptance_criteria fallback is gone; gateway delegate returns
incomplete_input with populated field_hints when criteria are missing.
The 2026-05-10 smoke run that produced skeleton tasks no longer can.
Phases 2-4 (tracing, journaling, communications, agent_loop, housekeeping)
get their own plans.
* feat(foundation/policy): journaling scope catalog (5 panel-UI scopes)
* feat(foundation/policy/journaling): role read tiers + protected journals
* refactor(content_actions): derive _VALID_NOTE_SCOPES from foundation.journaling
* refactor(services/journal): derive _SCOPE_TO_TYPE from foundation.journaling
* refactor(enforcement/journal_perms): import read-tier rules from foundation
PROTECTED_JOURNALS + ROLE_READ_TIERS now sourced from foundation.policy.journaling.
The local helpers (_check_protected_access, _check_cell_pm_access,
_check_cell_member_access) are collapsed into a single tier-driven check via
_decide_protected / _decide_by_tier. Pre-Phase-2 GLOBAL_READERS that lumped
CEO/auditor/PO/HoM/main_pm together is split into ReadTier.ALL (ceo+auditor —
includes protected) vs ReadTier.ALL_CELLS (others — excludes protected).
Observable behavior preserved.
* feat(foundation/policy): tracing Requirement enum + check_requirements
19 requirements (16 from pre-Phase-2 tracing_gate + 3 pre-gateway parity:
JOURNAL_NOTE_AT_CLAIM, JOURNAL_DECISION_AT_CLAIM, JOURNAL_DURING_WORK).
GateContext expanded with the new presence flags and journal_during_work_count.
Acceptance-criteria checker keeps the spec §9 item 1 reflect-note shortcut.
* feat(foundation/policy/tracing): VERB_REQUIREMENTS table + verb parity validator
Maps every gateway intent verb to its required-set. Includes the 6 inline
journal:decision callsites (submit_up, complete, unblock, escalate_up,
escalate_to_ceo, delegate) plus the 4 pre-gateway parity additions
(NOTE_AT_CLAIM, DECISION_AT_CLAIM, REFLECT on complete, DURING_WORK).
Validator asserts every spec verb is covered or explicitly waived, and
every Requirement enum value is used by at least one verb.
PLAN added to i_will_work_on / i_will_plan (mirrors spec.PRECONDITION_PLAN
in the tracing layer). SELF_VERIFIED added to i_am_done as a defense-in-depth
backstop (auto-set by the in_progress→verifying transition).
* refactor(gateway/i_am_done): tracing gates via foundation.policy.tracing
Adds JOURNAL_DURING_WORK_AT_LEAST_ONE check (pre-gateway parity P2 —
agents must write at least one decision/learning/struggle entry between
claim and submit). Adds journal.has_struggle_for_task helper.
Replaces the pre-Phase-2 tracing_gate.check_requirements call.
SELF_VERIFIED is filtered from the pre-flight required-set: the spec
composes (submit_verification, submit_qa) for i_am_done and the
auto-run submit_verification flips self_verified=True before submit_qa
runs. The flag therefore acts as a defense-in-depth backstop AFTER the
spec, not before — checking it pre-flight would block the auto-verify
path. SELF_VERIFIED stays in the foundation required-set and is
re-asserted by the spec action's own preconditions.
Test fixtures updated: 9 i_am_done success-path tests now mock
has_decision_for_task=True (or equivalent) so the new during-work
cadence gate is satisfied. NO_PR-token assertion broadened to also
accept the foundation token "pr_open".
* refactor(gateway/qa): pass/fail gates via foundation.policy.tracing
* refactor(gateway/doc): i_documented gates via foundation.policy.tracing
Doc-specific missing-key translations (docs_notes>=min, docs_files_non_empty)
added to the central _build_tracing_gap translator established in Task 9.
* refactor(gateway): unify 6 inline journal:decision checks via tracing.check_requirements
Pre-Phase-2 inline blocks at _impl.py lines ~2230/2394/2442/2574/2814/2895
each ran the same has_decision_for_task + Envelope.tracing_gap pattern. They
now call:
- _check_pm_decision_required(verb, ...) — for unblock, escalate_up,
escalate_to_ceo, delegate. Each declares only JOURNAL_DECISION in
VERB_REQUIREMENTS, so a single helper consuming
tracing.requirements_for(verb) suffices.
- _check_complete_gates — for cell_pm_complete and main_pm_complete.
Consumes VERB_REQUIREMENTS["complete"] = JOURNAL_DECISION + JOURNAL_REFLECT
+ NOTES_MIN_CHARS. The inline _subtasks_not_terminal_envelope is kept
because its remediation enumerates the non-terminal subtask ids — strictly
richer than the foundation hint.
- _check_submit_up_gates — for submit_up. Consumes
VERB_REQUIREMENTS["submit_up"] minus SUBTASKS_TERMINAL (deferred to the
inline envelope for the same reason as complete).
Also adds the journal:decision tracing gate to the delegate verb
(VERB_REQUIREMENTS["delegate"] = {JOURNAL_DECISION}) — pre-gateway PM.md
required journal:decision before each delegate, but the gateway path had
not yet enforced it. Threaded into _delegate_extra_guards so the verb
body's return count stays under the lint cap.
_build_tracing_gap gains hint translations for journal:decision, notes>=min,
and subtasks_terminal. The body is refactored to a static dispatch table
+ acceptance-criteria batch handler so the branch count stays under the
lint cap.
PM-verb success-path tests updated to provide notes >= 20 chars (the new
NOTES_MIN_CHARS gate); has_reflect_for_task mocks added to a few tests
where they're now load-bearing (AsyncMock truthiness covers most).
6575 tests passing, mypy + ruff clean.
* feat(gateway/claim): require journal:note_at_claim and journal:decision_at_claim
Pre-gateway parity P1, P3: developers wrote a note (scope='note') on
every claim; PMs wrote a decision (scope='decision') on plan. Restored
via foundation.policy.tracing requirements wired through a new
_post_claim_journal_gate helper that runs AFTER the composed
(claim, set_plan, start) sequence completes.
Failed checks return tracing_gap with a remediate hint that tells the
agent to journal then retry. The claim itself stays — the agent
journals and re-issues the verb (idempotent re-entry shortcuts back
to OK once the entry is present).
Adds journal.has_note_for_task helper paralleling
has_decision/reflect/learning/struggle. The PLAN requirement is
filtered out of the post-claim check because spec.PRECONDITION_PLAN
already enforced it before the runner ran — re-asserting at the
tracing layer would emit a misleading hint.
Two new tests verify the gate fires for missing note/decision; existing
success-path tests already mock the journal service via AsyncMock
(returning truthy) so no regressions.
* test(foundation): Phase 2 smoke gate + tracing_gate.py deleted
Phase 2 closes here:
- foundation/policy/journaling.py owns the 5-scope catalog + read tiers
- foundation/policy/tracing.py owns Requirement enum + VERB_REQUIREMENTS
- 6 inline journal:decision checks replaced with unified helpers
- pre-gateway parity restored: NOTE_AT_CLAIM, DECISION_AT_CLAIM,
DURING_WORK, REFLECT-on-complete
- services/gateway/tracing_gate.py deleted
- enforcement/journal_perms.py read-tier rules canonicalized
Smoke gate 2 enforces: no inline has_decision_for_task remains; every
intent verb has a tracing decision; tracing_gate module is gone.
* fix(foundation/task_completeness): align hint strings with actual enum values
_HINT_NATURE listed 5 values (technical | bugfix | feature | refactor | docs)
but TaskNature only has 2 (TECHNICAL / NON_TECHNICAL). _HINT_ESTIMATED_COMPLEXITY
listed "critical" which Complexity doesn't have. _HINT_TEAM omitted FULLSTACK
(real, used) and didn't note that MARKETING is legacy seed-data. _HINT_TASK_TYPE
was already correct.
Hints now reflect the actual enums in roboco/models/base.py and
roboco/foundation/identity.py — agents reading the gateway's incomplete_input
remediate envelopes will no longer be told to send values the enums reject.
Tests using nature="feature" (DelegateRequest's nature is `str`, not the
enum, so it accepted the fake value silently) updated to nature="technical"
so they exercise a real enum value end-to-end.
* fix(orchestrator): remove dead "critical" complexity branches
Complexity enum has only LOW / MEDIUM / HIGH — no CRITICAL value.
The three "critical" branches in dispatch logic at lines ~3032 / 3331 /
5049 were dead code (the comparison can never be true). Removed.
Surfaced during Phase 2 closeout when the foundation hint string was
audited against the actual enum.
* feat(foundation/policy/communications): Priority + NOTIFY_SENDER_ROLES + ACK_REQUIRED_BY_TYPE
* feat(foundation/policy/communications): CHANNELS catalog (channel topology)
* refactor(agents_config): derive CHANNEL_ACCESS from foundation.communications
* refactor(seeds): derive DEFAULT_CHANNELS / CHANNEL_MEMBERSHIPS from foundation
* refactor(content_actions): derive notify allowlist + priorities from foundation
Replaces _NOTIFY_ALLOWED_ROLES + _VALID_NOTIFY_PRIORITIES literals with
derivations from foundation.communications.NOTIFY_SENDER_ROLES + Priority.
Behavior change: pre-Phase-3 the literal frozenset {cell_pm, main_pm,
product_owner, head_marketing} excluded CEO. Foundation includes CEO
(per spec 5.5). The contradiction with agents_config.NOTIFICATION_PERMISSIONS
(which already granted CEO can_send=True) is now resolved.
* refactor(notification_delivery): requires_ack from foundation.ACK_REQUIRED_BY_TYPE
* refactor(enforcement,agents_config): delete dead notification policy
- enforcement/notification_perms.py deleted (dead at call-graph; only
the enforcement/__init__.py re-export kept it reachable, and that
re-export is gone too).
- agents_config.NOTIFICATION_PERMISSIONS dict deleted; agents_config
.can_send_notifications now derives from
foundation.policy.communications.NOTIFY_SENDER_ROLES (auditor
correctly excluded — silent observer per spec §5.5).
- services/permissions.py: _can_role_send_notifications and
can_agent_send_notifications now derive from NOTIFY_SENDER_ROLES;
_get_notification_scope encodes the scope rule (cell/all/list)
locally as a function-of-role and returns list[AgentRole] instead
of list[slug]; can_notify list-scope branch updated to match.
- enforcement/__init__.py: removed the notification_perms re-export
and the NotificationPermissionError, get_notification_scope,
validate_notification_permission names from __all__.
Closes the spec §3 contradiction: gateway content_actions
._NOTIFY_ALLOWED_ROLES (Task 5) and the legacy
agents_config.NOTIFICATION_PERMISSIONS no longer disagree about
whether auditor may call notify(). Both now derive from
foundation.NOTIFY_SENDER_ROLES.
* fix(content_actions): runtime auditor guard in say/dm (defense in depth)
Closes the spec §5.5 gap where the auditor's silent role was enforced
ONLY by manifest exclusion. The manifest pre-filters the tool surface
exposed to the auditor agent, but if anything bypassed it, the auditor
could speak. The new runtime guard in ContentActions.say/dm refuses
with Envelope.not_authorized when the caller's role is "auditor",
regardless of how the call arrived.
* fix(a2a): pass Priority tristate end-to-end (was reduced to boolean)
Pre-Phase-3 path:
request priority: str -> services/a2a.py reduces to urgent: bool
-> services/notification.py maps bool back to NotificationPriority
This made Priority.HIGH unreachable through the A2A path.
After this fix the full tristate (NORMAL/HIGH/URGENT) survives end-to-end:
* services/a2a.py:create_a2a_notification parses metadata["priority"]
(preferred) or falls back to legacy metadata["urgent"] / config.urgent
(URGENT-only). Unknown values fall back to NORMAL.
* services/notification.py:send_a2a_notification now takes
a2a_context["priority"] (NotificationPriority); a defensive bool/str
coerce keeps legacy callers from crashing.
* runtime/orchestrator.py:_build_a2a_prompt reads priority off the
notification row (the source of truth) instead of a non-existent
metadata.urgent and renders three tiers: URGENT bold, HIGH softer,
NORMAL no prefix.
Cosmetic [URGENT] body/subject prefix stays urgent-only; HIGH gets no
prefix but is recorded as HIGH at the NotificationTable.priority column.
Tests:
* 9 new tests in tests/integration/test_a2a_priority_tristate.py
pinning the round-trip for HIGH/NORMAL/URGENT through both layers
plus legacy-bool backcompat.
* Updated tests/unit/services/test_notification.py::test_send_a2a_notification
to the new priority= contract.
Closes the spec section 3 contradiction flagged in the audit.
* feat(foundation/policy): agent_loop BudgetPolicy + VERB_RETRY_LIMITS
* refactor(agent_sdk): import budget thresholds from foundation
* refactor(orchestrator): import _PM_RESPAWN_MAX_UNPRODUCTIVE from foundation
* fix(post-tool-budget-hook): exit 1 on loop-halt (was exit 0 / non-blocking)
Pre-Phase-3 the hook printed [Loop] and exit 0'd — agents could ignore it
and keep retrying. The 2026-05-10 smoke run showed i_am_done retried 5+
times within the global 150-tool budget, never hitting a real wall.
Now the hook reads the SDK response's loop_action field (sourced from
foundation.BudgetPolicy.loop_action; default "halt") and exits 1 to
deny the wrapping tool call when the rolling-window loop detector fires
AND loop_action is "halt". Operators can soften via env
ROBOCO_AGENT_LOOP_ACTION=warn for debugging.
Changes:
- BudgetStatus pydantic model: add loop_action: Literal["warn", "halt"]
(default "halt") so the SDK response carries the policy.
- agent_sdk/server.py: read ROBOCO_AGENT_LOOP_ACTION env override on top
of foundation default and surface it in _budget_snapshot().
- post-tool-budget-hook.sh: parse .loop_action, exit 1 to stderr when
loop+halt; falls back to legacy warn-only print if the field is
missing (older SDK / partial deploy).
* feat(agent_sdk): per-verb retry circuit breaker via foundation.VERB_RETRY_LIMITS
Pre-Phase-3 the gateway had no per-verb retry cap. The 2026-05-10 smoke
showed i_am_done retried 5+ times in 2 minutes within the global 150-tool
budget — the agent never hit a real wall.
Now the SDK tracks (verb, task_id) -> deque[timestamp] over a 60s sliding
window. When the count for a verb exceeds foundation.retry_limit_for(verb),
the next attempt receives Envelope.circuit_open with a remediate hint
pointing to i_am_blocked / i_am_idle as graceful exits.
Verbs in foundation.UNLIMITED_RETRY_VERBS (give_me_work, triage,
evidence, etc.) bypass the breaker. Only rejection envelopes
(tracing_gap, invalid_state, not_authorized, incomplete_input) feed
the counter — successful calls do not count.
Wire-up:
- Envelope.circuit_open classmethod + as_dict pass-through
- _SessionState.verb_attempts: defaultdict[(verb, task_id), deque[float]]
- Helpers _record_verb_attempt / _verb_attempt_count / _check_verb_circuit
- POST /verb/attempted: hook posts after a rejected gateway call;
response carries breaker state + (when open) the wire-format
Envelope.circuit_open dict the agent should surface to itself
- GET /verb/circuit_status: read-only state probe
- _state.reset() (also POST /budget/reset) wipes the tracker on spawn
* test(foundation): Phase 3 smoke gate + foundation-check extended
Phase 3 closes here:
- foundation/policy/communications.py owns Priority, NOTIFY_SENDER_ROLES,
ACK_REQUIRED_BY_TYPE, ChannelSpec, CHANNELS, parse_priority
- foundation/policy/agent_loop.py owns BudgetPolicy, VERB_RETRY_LIMITS,
UNLIMITED_RETRY_VERBS, retry_limit_for
- 6 channel topology fork sites collapsed to one source (CHANNELS)
- Notification sender contradiction closed (CEO included; auditor excluded)
- A2A urgency tristate restored (HIGH reachable end-to-end); A2A
service now consumes parse_priority instead of inlining branches
(also drops create_a2a_notification CC from C/13 to A/<10)
- Auditor silent role enforced at runtime in say/dm
- enforcement/notification_perms.py deleted (was dead code)
- 7 hand-set requires_ack callsites consolidated to ACK_REQUIRED_BY_TYPE
- post-tool-budget-hook.sh exits 1 on loop-halt
- Per-verb retry circuit breaker live in agent_sdk (60s sliding window)
make foundation-check now validates communications + tracing + journaling
+ identity drift in one command. make quality green.
* refactor(lifecycle): copy spec.py to foundation/policy/lifecycle.py + shim
Phase 4 Task 1 — relocates the canonical lifecycle spec next to its policy
siblings (task_completeness, tracing, journaling, communications, agent_loop).
The original roboco/lifecycle/spec.py is now an explicit re-export shim;
consumers continue to work unchanged. Subsequent Phase 4 tasks (2-7) migrate
the imports in batches, then Task 8 deletes the shim.
No behavior change — pure code move.
* refactor(services): import lifecycle from foundation (Phase 4 batch)
* refactor(agents,enforcement): import lifecycle from foundation (Phase 4 batch)
* refactor(tests): import lifecycle from foundation (Phase 4 batch)
* refactor(foundation): absorb lifecycle _validate + _generators
Phase 4 Tasks 9 + 10. Moves the lifecycle spec's internal validators
to roboco/foundation/_validate_lifecycle.py and its RAG/prompt artifact
emitter to roboco/foundation/_generators.py.
The lifecycle validators live in a sibling module (not merged with
foundation/_validate.py) because the lifecycle spec imports from
foundation at module load — placing the lifecycle checks alongside the
identity checks would create an import cycle between
roboco.foundation and roboco.foundation.policy.lifecycle (the latter
calls the validators at the bottom of its own definition). The
_validate_lifecycle module defers its policy.lifecycle imports to
function bodies so it loads cleanly when the spec hasn't finished
initialising yet; the per-file PLC0415 exemption in pyproject.toml
documents the reason.
Test files relocated:
- tests/lifecycle/test_spec.py -> tests/foundation/test_lifecycle_spec.py
- tests/lifecycle/test_generators.py -> tests/foundation/test_lifecycle_generators.py
scripts/build_lifecycle_artifacts.py now imports the generators from
roboco.foundation; the on-disk artifacts (docs/rag/lifecycle,
panel/lib/lifecycle.json, agents/prompts/_generated/lifecycle-*.md)
regenerate byte-identically.
After this commit, roboco/lifecycle/ contains only the spec.py and
__init__.py re-export shims — Task 8 deletes those.
No behavior change. 6638 tests pass; make quality green.
* refactor(lifecycle): delete legacy roboco/lifecycle/ package
Phase 4 Task 8. All consumers migrated to roboco.foundation.policy.lifecycle
in Tasks 2-7; the internal validators + generators moved to foundation in
Tasks 9-10. The legacy package contained only re-export shims.
Also trims tests/foundation/test_role_reexport.py — the two assertions that
checked the lifecycle.spec shim's object-identity are gone with the shim.
The two models.base shim assertions (AgentRole / Team) are still
meaningful and stay.
Inline docstrings / comments in enforcement/task_lifecycle.py,
services/gateway/role_config.py, services/gateway/content_actions.py,
tests/integration/test_task_service_lifecycle_misc.py and
foundation/policy/lifecycle.py that referenced the now-deleted
roboco.lifecycle.spec module are updated to point at
roboco.foundation.policy.lifecycle.
After this commit, roboco.lifecycle is gone. Lifecycle policy lives only
at roboco.foundation.policy.lifecycle. Adding new lifecycle rules edits
exactly that one file.
* refactor(api): consolidate route-guard role-sets via foundation
Replace hand-written role-name string frozensets in roboco/api/deps.py
(_PM_OR_ABOVE_ROLES, _DEVELOPER_OR_ABOVE_ROLES, _GLOBAL_CELL_ACCESS_ROLES)
and roboco/api/routes/v2/_role_dep.py (require_dev/qa/doc/cell_pm/main_pm/
board/auditor) with foundation-derived expressions over PM_ROLES,
BOARD_ROLES, DEV_ROLES, and Role enum members.
Behavior is preserved: Role is a StrEnum, so the lowercase X-Agent-Role
header still compares equal to its matching member. HEAD_MARKETING stays
excluded from every -or-above set (marketing spokesperson, not approver);
the carve-out is now expressed as (BOARD_ROLES - {Role.HEAD_MARKETING})
instead of an opaque literal.
Adds tests/foundation/test_route_guard_consolidation.py (6 tests) pinning
both the foundation-derived membership and the import contract.
* test(foundation): Phase 4 smoke gate + housekeeping closeout
Phase 4 closes the foundation canonicalization effort (Phases 1-4 spanning
2026-05-10 -> 2026-05-11):
Phase 1 - identity + task_completeness (skeleton-task bug killed)
Phase 2 - tracing + journaling (pre-gateway cadence restored)
Phase 3 - communications + agent_loop (channel/notification/A2A/circuit-breaker)
Phase 4 - housekeeping (lifecycle moved to foundation; consumers migrated)
All cross-cutting policy now lives in roboco/foundation/. Adding a policy
edits exactly one file. The legacy roboco.lifecycle package is gone.
Smoke gates 1-4 enforce: no skeleton tasks, no inline journal:decision
checks, channel topology canonical, A2A tristate preserved, auditor silent
at runtime, lifecycle module path canonical.
make quality + make foundation-check both green.
* fix(mcp/agent_sdk): wire per-verb circuit breaker into response handler
Phase 3 Task 14 added the SDK infrastructure (tracker, endpoints,
Envelope.circuit_open, retry_limit_for) but nothing was actually
recording rejections — the breaker never tripped. This commit wires
the gateway-response path so every rejection envelope (tracing_gap /
invalid_state / not_authorized / incomplete_input) hits
POST /verb/attempted, and if the breaker is open, the envelope is
substituted with the circuit_open response before the agent sees it.
Best-effort: SDK-unreachable / malformed-response failures fall open
(agent sees the original rejection), so the breaker never breaks the
gateway path.
* fix(notification_delivery): retype CEO approval-flow notifications APPROVAL
notify_assignee_of_ceo_rejection and notify_ceo_of_escalation were both
typed NotificationType.TASK_ASSIGNMENT, which the Phase 3 foundation
table (ACK_REQUIRED_BY_TYPE in roboco/foundation/policy/communications.py)
maps to requires_ack=False. Both are approval-flow notifications and
should mandate acknowledgment.
Retyped both to NotificationType.APPROVAL so the table lookup yields
requires_ack=True via ACK_REQUIRED_BY_TYPE[NotificationType.APPROVAL].
* test(foundation): move lifecycle parity + smoke-replay tests under tests/foundation/
Phase 4 Task 8 deleted roboco/lifecycle/ but tests/lifecycle/ still held
two files importing roboco.foundation.policy.lifecycle. Mirror the layout
of test_lifecycle_spec.py and test_lifecycle_generators.py (moved in
Phase 4 Tasks 9+10) by relocating them under tests/foundation/ with the
test_lifecycle_* prefix, then delete the now-empty tests/lifecycle/
package.
tests/lifecycle/test_consumer_parity.py
-> tests/foundation/test_lifecycle_consumer_parity.py
tests/lifecycle/test_smoke_replay.py
-> tests/foundation/test_lifecycle_smoke_replay.py
* build(make): consolidate ci-lifecycle-check into foundation-check
ci-lifecycle-check was a thin wrapper that regenerated lifecycle artifacts
via scripts/build_lifecycle_artifacts.py and gated on git diff. After
Phase 4 it sat alongside foundation-check covering the same drift-gate
intent. Merge the lifecycle-artifact regen + git-diff step into
foundation-check so a single 'make foundation-check' is the canonical
drift gate.
Keep ci-lifecycle-check as a phony alias forwarding to foundation-check
for any external script or CI lane still using the old target name.
Drop the redundant ci-lifecycle-check call from 'make quality'.
* ++
---------
Co-authored-by: Renn F <rennf93@users.noreply.github.com>
